Chowdhry Nita, Aleksejūnienė Jolanta, Wyatt Chris, Bryant Ross
Faculty of Dentistry, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, BC, Canada.
J Can Dent Assoc. 2011;77:b21.
To compare the perceptions of dentists in British Columbia regarding their decisions to provide treatment in long-term care facilities and to explore changes since 1985 in Vancouver dentists' attitudes to treating elderly patients in such facilities.
Dentists were randomly selected from all of British Columbia in 2008 and surveyed with a similar questionnaire to that used for a 1985 study of Vancouver dentists. The attitudes of current dentists, the patterns of their perceptions and trends over time were analyzed.
Of the 800 BC dentists approached for the survey in 2008, 251 replied (31% response rate). Only 37 (15%) of these respondents were providing treatment in long-term care facilities, and another 48 (19%) had stopped providing services in this setting. Among those providing care, important considerations were continuing education in geriatrics, the presence of a dental team and fee-for-service payment. The most common reasons for deciding to provide services in long-term care facilities were to increase the number of patients being served and to broaden clinical practice. Dentists who had stopped treating patients in long-term care facilities reported their perception that treating elderly people is financially unrewarding and professionally unsatisfying. The perceptions of dentists shifted substantially from 1985 to 2008. In particular, dentists responding to the 2008 survey who had never provided services in long-term care facilities were more likely to perceive administrative difficulties and a lack of financial reward as barriers than those surveyed in 1985. In addition, the proportion of Vancouver dentists with advanced education in geriatrics declined over the period between the 2 studies (75 [22%] of 334 in 1985, 10 [11%] of 87 in 2008).
Dentists who did not provide care for residents of long-term care facilities in 2008 seemed more likely to be deterred by administrative difficulties and financial costs than those not providing such care in 1985. In addition, fewer dentists had appropriate training in geriatrics. Continuing education, working with a dental team and payment on a fee-for-service basis were important factors for dentists who were providing care in such facilities.
比较不列颠哥伦比亚省牙医对于其在长期护理机构提供治疗的决策的看法,并探究自1985年以来温哥华牙医对在这类机构治疗老年患者的态度变化。
2008年从整个不列颠哥伦比亚省随机选取牙医,并用一份与1985年用于研究温哥华牙医的问卷类似的问卷进行调查。分析了当前牙医的态度、他们的认知模式以及随时间的趋势。
在2008年被邀请参与调查的800名不列颠哥伦比亚省牙医中,251人回复(回复率31%)。这些受访者中只有37人(15%)在长期护理机构提供治疗,另外48人(19%)已停止在这种环境下提供服务。在提供护理的人员中,重要的考虑因素包括老年病学继续教育、牙科团队的存在以及按服务收费。决定在长期护理机构提供服务的最常见原因是增加服务患者数量和拓宽临床实践。已停止在长期护理机构治疗患者的牙医表示,他们认为治疗老年人在经济上没有回报且在专业上不满足。从1985年到2008年,牙医的看法发生了很大变化。特别是,2008年参与调查且从未在长期护理机构提供过服务的牙医比1985年接受调查的牙医更有可能将行政困难和缺乏经济回报视为障碍。此外,在这两项研究期间,接受过老年病学高等教育的温哥华牙医比例有所下降(1985年334人中的75人[22%],2008年87人中的10人[11%])。
2008年未为长期护理机构居民提供护理的牙医似乎比1985年未提供此类护理的牙医更容易受到行政困难和财务成本的阻碍。此外,接受老年病学适当培训的牙医更少。继续教育、与牙科团队合作以及按服务收费是在这类机构提供护理的牙医的重要因素。