Department of Diagnostic Radiology, Li Ka Shing Faculty of Medicine, The University of Hong Kong, and Radiology Department, Kwong Wah Hospital, Hong Kong.
Eur J Radiol. 2012 Mar;81(3):e264-8. doi: 10.1016/j.ejrad.2011.02.022. Epub 2011 Mar 24.
To assess the knowledge and practice pertaining to radiation exposure related to radiological imaging among medical doctors, in relation to specialty and year of experience.
Questionnaires as recommended by the United Nations Scientific Committee on the Effects of Atomic Radiation (UNSCEAR) were distributed to doctors in tertiary hospitals by convenience sampling. Their knowledge of radiation doses of common radiological investigations was assessed by any significant difference from correct answers by sampled t-test. Comparison between specialties and between the more (>6 years experience) and less experienced doctors was made by pairwise comparisons of 'right answer minus mean difference (RMD)' using Wilcoxon Signed Ranks Test. Descriptive analysis of their knowledge of harmful effects of radiation and the practices pertaining were also performed.
Total 93 questionnaires were sent out and 82 (88.2%, 40 interns, 24 clinicians, 18 radiologists) were returned. Radiologists had the least deviation from correct answers compared to interns (1.29 vs. 2.40, p=0.018) and physicians (1.29 vs. 2.57, p=0.046). More-experienced doctors also performed better than the less-experienced (1.69 vs. 2.57, p=0.027). 12/80 (15%) and 4/80 (5%) failed to recognize MR and US as radiation-free modalities. Only 10/80 (12.5%) knew the risk of carcinogenesis from abdominal CT and only 4/81 (5%) will discuss radiation-related hazard with patients routinely.
Knowledge of medical doctors, including radiologists, towards radiation exposure of imaging is unsatisfactory and could imply a tendency of radiation misuse and under-utilization of alternative radiation-free methods. On-job training and discussion of the radiation risk with patients are advised.
评估与放射影像学相关的辐射暴露方面的知识和实践,与专业和经验年限有关。
采用联合国原子辐射效应科学委员会(UNSCEAR)推荐的问卷,通过便利抽样法向三级医院的医生发放问卷。通过样本 t 检验评估他们对常见放射学检查的辐射剂量的了解,与正确答案有任何显著差异的视为错误。通过Wilcoxon 符号秩检验比较不同专业和经验丰富(>6 年经验)与经验较少医生之间的差异,使用“正确答案减去平均差异(RMD)”进行两两比较。还对他们关于辐射危害的知识和实践进行了描述性分析。
共发出 93 份问卷,收回 82 份(88.2%,40 名实习生、24 名临床医生、18 名放射科医生)。与实习生(1.29 比 2.40,p=0.018)和医生(1.29 比 2.57,p=0.046)相比,放射科医生的答案与正确答案的偏差最小。经验丰富的医生表现也优于经验较少的医生(1.69 比 2.57,p=0.027)。80 名医生中有 12 名(15%)和 4 名(5%)未能认识到磁共振成像(MR)和超声(US)是无辐射的方式。只有 10 名(12.5%)医生知道腹部 CT 致癌风险,只有 4 名(5%)医生会常规与患者讨论与辐射相关的危害。
包括放射科医生在内的医生对影像学辐射暴露的了解并不令人满意,这可能意味着存在辐射滥用和对无辐射替代方法利用不足的倾向。建议进行在职培训并与患者讨论辐射风险。