Barnawi Rashid A, Alrefai Weaam M, Qari Faris, Aljefri Ahmed, Hagi Sarah K, Khafaji Mawya
Department of Radiology, Faculty of Medicine, King Abdulaziz University, Jeddah, Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. E-mail.
Saudi Med J. 2018 Nov;39(11):1130-1138. doi: 10.15537/smj.2018.11.23091.
To assess emergency doctors' knowledge of radiation exposure doses and risks, and the increasing use of radiological investigations in emergency medicine practice is very concerning because of the associated risks of cancer.
Doctors from different specialties and with different levels of training working in emergency departments of 8 hospitals in Jeddah, Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, filled out a questionnaire. Participants estimated the radiation doses of different imaging modalities and answered questions regarding possible associated risks. Results: One hundred seventy-one doctors returned completed questionnaires. The overall correct dose estimation rate was 20.8%. Doses were more correctly estimated by consultants versus specialists and residents (p=0.007), and by emergency physicians versus doctors from other specialties (p=0.05). The correct answer rate was insignificantly higher among doctors with formal training on radiation protection (p=0.065). The overall correct answer rate was unsatisfactory for 4 questions assessing physicians' knowledge of risks. Questions about the lifetime risk of cancer due to ionizing radiation were more correctly answered by consultants versus residents and specialists (p=0.05). Specialists were more knowledgeable about the risk of imaging on fetuses (p=0.05). Doctors with formal training answered 3 out of 4 questions more correctly than doctors without formal training, but no difference existed between them regarding imaging modalities, that they selected for pregnant patients (p=0.297). Conclusion: Doctors working in emergency departments had poor knowledge about radiation doses and risks. This issue warrants urgent attention.
评估急诊医生对辐射暴露剂量和风险的了解情况,鉴于放射学检查在急诊医学实践中的使用日益增加且存在癌症相关风险,这一情况令人十分担忧。
沙特阿拉伯王国吉达市8家医院急诊科的不同专业、不同培训水平的医生填写了一份问卷。参与者估计了不同成像方式的辐射剂量,并回答了有关可能相关风险的问题。结果:171名医生返回了完整的问卷。总体正确剂量估计率为20.8%。顾问医生比专科医生和住院医生更能正确估计剂量(p = 0.007),急诊医生比其他专业的医生更能正确估计剂量(p = 0.05)。接受过辐射防护正规培训的医生的正确答案率略高(p = 0.065)。在评估医生风险知识的4个问题中,总体正确答案率并不理想。关于电离辐射导致癌症的终生风险的问题,顾问医生比住院医生和专科医生回答得更正确(p = 0.05)。专科医生对胎儿成像风险的了解更多(p = 0.05)。接受过正规培训的医生在4个问题中有3个回答得比未接受过正规培训的医生更正确,但在为孕妇选择的成像方式方面,他们之间没有差异(p = 0.297)。结论:急诊科医生对辐射剂量和风险的了解较差。这个问题值得紧急关注。