Department of Psychology, Washington State University-Vancouver, Vancouver, WA 98686, USA.
Psychol Addict Behav. 2011 Mar;25(1):162-7. doi: 10.1037/a0022254.
Determining whether a particular treatment works for specific groups of people can help tailor dissemination of evidence-based alcohol treatments. It has been proposed that individuals from different racial groups might have better outcomes in treatments that are sensitive to sociocultural issues that impact alcohol use among these groups. The current study was a secondary analysis of data from the combined behavioral intervention (CBI) condition of the COMBINE study. Those randomly assigned to CBI (n = 776) had the opportunity to receive up to 9 skills training modules, which were chosen by the therapist. The goal of the current study was to determine whether receiving 1 of the CBI modules, drink refusal and social pressure skills training, predicted differential outcomes among African American clients. Results indicated that African American clients who received the drink refusal skills training module (n = 25) had significantly fewer heavy drinking days (d = 0.79) 1 year following treatment than African Americans clients who did not receive the module (n = 35). African American clients who received the module also had significantly fewer heavy drinking days (d = 0.86) than non-Hispanic White clients who received the module (n = 241). Good clinical outcomes at 1 year posttreatment were observed among 80% of African Americans who received the module, compared with 54% of African Americans who did not receive the module and 52% of non-Hispanic White clients who did receive the module. Although small sample size limits interpretation, findings provide preliminary evidence supporting the inclusion of drink refusal skills training as part of alcohol interventions for African American clients.
确定特定治疗方法是否对特定人群有效,可以帮助针对基于证据的酒精治疗方法进行传播。有人提出,不同种族群体的个体在那些对影响这些群体饮酒行为的社会文化问题敏感的治疗方法中可能会有更好的效果。本研究是 COMBINE 研究联合行为干预(CBI)条件下数据的二次分析。那些被随机分配到 CBI(n=776)的人有机会接受多达 9 个技能培训模块,这些模块由治疗师选择。本研究的目的是确定接受 CBI 模块之一(拒绝饮酒和社会压力技能培训)是否能预测非裔美国客户的不同结果。结果表明,接受拒绝饮酒技能培训模块的非裔美国客户(n=25)在治疗后 1 年的重度饮酒天数(d=0.79)显著少于未接受该模块的非裔美国客户(n=35)。接受该模块的非裔美国客户(d=0.86)的重度饮酒天数也明显少于接受该模块的非西班牙裔白种客户(n=241)。在治疗后 1 年,接受该模块的 80%的非裔美国客户出现了良好的临床效果,而未接受该模块的 54%的非裔美国客户和接受该模块的 52%的非西班牙裔白种客户出现了良好的临床效果。尽管样本量小限制了解释,但这些发现提供了初步证据,支持将拒绝饮酒技能培训纳入针对非裔美国客户的酒精干预措施。