Brower Kirk J, Carey Theadia L
Department of Psychiatry, University of Michigan Medical School, Ann Arbor, Michigan 48108, USA.
Alcohol Clin Exp Res. 2003 Aug;27(8):1365-7. doi: 10.1097/01.ALC.0000080165.72243.03.
Published studies comparing the outcomes of black and white patients with alcohol dependence have produced mixed results. We hypothesized that among alcoholic outpatients blacks would have worse outcomes than whites. A sample of 38 blacks and 136 whites were assessed prospectively at baseline and 6-12 months using a naturalistic study design. At baseline, blacks had less education, employment, and income than whites, and they were less likely to be married. They also were more likely to have family histories of substance abuse, previous episodes of treatment, cocaine use disorders, antisocial personality disorder, and poor physical health. Between baseline and follow-up, blacks received less treatment for alcohol dependence than whites. Such differences would seem to favor worse outcomes which were not found. Blacks, however, reported more social support for sobriety than whites. They also had better rates of study retention than whites, suggestive of either higher levels of motivation or stronger alliances with the treatment center. Future studies of racial differences should include measures of social support for sobriety, motivation for treatment, and treatment alliance.
已发表的比较酒精依赖的黑人和白人患者治疗结果的研究得出了不一致的结果。我们假设,在酒精依赖门诊患者中,黑人的治疗结果会比白人更差。采用自然主义研究设计,对38名黑人和136名白人样本在基线时以及6至12个月时进行了前瞻性评估。在基线时,黑人的教育程度、就业情况和收入都低于白人,而且他们结婚的可能性较小。他们也更有可能有药物滥用家族史、既往治疗史、可卡因使用障碍、反社会人格障碍以及身体健康状况不佳。在基线和随访之间,黑人接受的酒精依赖治疗比白人少。这些差异似乎预示着会有更差的治疗结果,但实际并未发现。然而,黑人报告称,他们在保持清醒方面得到的社会支持比白人更多。他们的研究留存率也比白人更高,这表明他们要么有更高的积极性,要么与治疗中心有更紧密的联系。未来关于种族差异的研究应纳入对保持清醒的社会支持、治疗动机和治疗联系的测量。