Clinique de Traumatologie et d'Orthopédie, 49, rue Hermite, 54000 Nancy, France.
Orthop Traumatol Surg Res. 2011 May;97(3):260-6. doi: 10.1016/j.otsr.2011.02.003. Epub 2011 Apr 1.
Shoulder arthroscopy is reputed to be painful, but progression of postoperative pain after this type of surgery has never been described and analyzed. This study had a triple objective: the description, search for risk factors, and analysis of the long-term impact of postoperative pain.
This continuous prospective series includes 231 patients who underwent arthroscopic shoulder surgery. Pain was evaluated from D-1 to D3, then at D7, D30, and 1 year. Three pain criteria were noted: visual analog scale (VAS), morphine intake, and satisfaction with pain management. Surgery was performed under general anesthesia and/or interscalene block. A local anesthetic complement was administered in one of four modes: single subacromial injection, subacromial catheter, intra-articular catheter, or no complement.
The VAS values remained less than 4 out of 10 during the entire study. Immediate postoperative pain was less than preoperative pain. It was followed by a pain bounce on D1 and D2 and did not return to a level significantly lower than its preoperative value until D30. Rotator cuff repair is the most painful surgery in the first postoperative days. The main risk factor for pain is a work related accident or occupational disease, associated with higher VAS values from D1 to 1 year and greater morphine intake. There was no correlation between immediate postoperative and 1-year VAS values.
DISCUSSION, CONCLUSION: Pain after shoulder arthroscopy is relatively low and the efficacy of the intervention is long-lasting in terms of pain symptom. A pain bounce appears on D1, which must be taken into account, notably in the context of outpatient surgery. The use of local anesthesia is therefore advantageous. Despite the efficacy of postoperative pain relief protocols, their effect on longer term perspective was not demonstrated.
肩关节镜手术被认为是疼痛的,但这种手术类型后的术后疼痛进展从未被描述和分析过。本研究有三个目的:描述、寻找危险因素,并分析术后疼痛的长期影响。
这是一项连续前瞻性系列研究,共纳入 231 例接受肩关节镜手术的患者。疼痛评估从 D-1 到 D-3,然后在 D-7、D-30 和 1 年时进行。记录了三个疼痛标准:视觉模拟评分(VAS)、吗啡摄入量和对疼痛管理的满意度。手术在全身麻醉和/或肌间沟阻滞下进行。局部麻醉补充剂以四种方式之一给予:单次肩峰下注射、肩峰下导管、关节内导管或无补充剂。
在整个研究过程中,VAS 值一直保持在 10 分以下。术后即刻疼痛小于术前疼痛。随后在 D-1 和 D-2 出现疼痛反弹,直到 D-30 才恢复到明显低于术前水平。肩袖修复术是术后头几天最疼痛的手术。疼痛的主要危险因素是与工作相关的事故或职业性疾病,与 D-1 至 1 年期间更高的 VAS 值和更大的吗啡摄入量相关。术后即刻 VAS 值与 1 年 VAS 值之间无相关性。
讨论,结论:肩关节镜手术后疼痛相对较低,干预措施在疼痛症状方面具有持久的疗效。在 D-1 出现疼痛反弹,这一点必须引起重视,尤其是在门诊手术的情况下。因此,使用局部麻醉剂是有利的。尽管术后疼痛缓解方案有效,但并未证明其对长期效果的影响。