Syracuse University, Department of Psychology, Syracuse, NY 13244, United States.
Clin Psychol Rev. 2011 Jun;31(4):673-83. doi: 10.1016/j.cpr.2011.02.007. Epub 2011 Mar 1.
Heavy alcohol use among college students has become a substantial health concern. With national survey data indicating that 40% of college students report consuming five or more alcoholic drinks at least monthly (Johnston, O'Malley, Bachman, & Schulenberg, 2009), prevention and intervention programs are needed to address this problem. The Task Force on College Drinking, commissioned by the National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism (NIAAA), designated alcohol expectancy challenges (ECs) as a recommended treatment strategy to reduce alcohol use among college students (NIAAA, 2002). This paper is a systematic critical review of the studies that have been conducted to assess for the efficacy of ECs among college students with a focus on changes in expectancies and alcohol consumption, and possible differences in efficacy for men and women. The review revealed that ECs were most efficacious when administered to male-only groups of participants; while ECs for female-only and mixed-gender groups demonstrated less consistent results. The implications of the findings of this critical review for the direction of future research are discussed.
大学生酗酒问题已成为一个严重的健康隐患。全国性调查数据显示,40%的大学生报告每月至少饮用五次或更多含酒精饮料(Johnston、O'Malley、Bachman 和 Schulenberg,2009),因此需要采取预防和干预措施来解决这一问题。美国国家酒精滥用与酒精中毒研究所(NIAAA)委托的大学生饮酒问题特别工作组将酒精预期挑战(ECs)指定为一种推荐的治疗策略,以减少大学生的饮酒量(NIAAA,2002)。本文是对已开展的评估 ECs 对大学生有效性的研究进行的系统批判性回顾,重点关注预期和饮酒量的变化,以及男性和女性的有效性可能存在差异。该综述显示,当 ECs 仅针对男性参与者群体实施时,效果最为显著;而仅针对女性或混合性别群体实施的 ECs 则产生了不太一致的结果。本文讨论了这一批判性综述的结果对未来研究方向的意义。