Chang Po-Chih, Hsu Yu-Chao, Shee Jia-Jen, Huang Shih-Tsung, Huang Hsin-Chieh, Chen Yu, Hsieh Ming-Li
Division of Urology, Department of Surgery, Chang Gung Memorial Hospital at Linkou, Chang Gung Memorial Hospital at Chiayi, Chang Gung University College of Medicine, Taoyuan, Taiwan.
Chang Gung Med J. 2011 Mar-Apr;34(2):179-85.
There are presently several options for the management of posterior urethral disruption. However, these options remain controversial for several reasons. Thus, this medical issue has been continuously investigated.
From 1991 to 2001, 22 patients with complete posterior urethral disruption out of 720 urethral injury cases were retrospectively reviewed using strict criteria. The 22 cases were grouped into two different management groups, the endoscopic early realignment (ER) group and the delayed urethrotomy (DU) group. The frequency of optic internal urethrotomy for urethral strictures and individual medical costs were evaluated over a two-year period.
The ER group had a mean frequency of 1.3 ± 0.82 urethrotomies in the first year and 1.8 ± 1.23 over two years while the DU group had a significantly higher urethrotomy frequency, 2.5 ± 1.35 in the first year and 4.1 ± 1.91 over two years. The costs for the DU group were 50% higher than the ER group at the end of second year.
An early endoscopic realignment operation saved up to NT 36,000 (New Taiwan Dollars) in costs with an average of 2.3 fewer further urethrotomy procedures in each case during the 2-year follow-up period. Therefore, early urethral realignment for traumatic complete posterior urethral disruption should be encouraged to prevent intractable urethral stricture and lower medical costs.
目前对于后尿道断裂的处理有多种选择。然而,由于多种原因,这些选择仍存在争议。因此,这一医学问题一直受到持续研究。
从1991年至2001年,对720例尿道损伤病例中22例完全性后尿道断裂患者进行回顾性研究,采用严格标准。将这22例患者分为两个不同的治疗组,即内镜早期复位(ER)组和延迟尿道切开术(DU)组。在两年期间评估尿道狭窄的直视下内尿道切开术频率及个体医疗费用。
ER组第一年尿道切开术平均频率为1.3±0.82次,两年为1.8±1.23次;而DU组尿道切开术频率显著更高,第一年为2.5±1.35次,两年为4.1±1.91次。第二年年底,DU组费用比ER组高50%。
早期内镜复位手术在两年随访期内,每例患者平均节省高达新台币36,000元的费用,且进一步尿道切开术平均减少2.3次。因此,对于创伤性完全性后尿道断裂应鼓励早期尿道复位,以预防难治性尿道狭窄并降低医疗费用。