Clemmensen Dorte, Thygesen Mathias, Rasmussen Mikkel Mylius, Fenger-Grøn Morten, Petersen Olav B, Mosdal Claus
The Spinal Cord Research Centre, Department of Neurosurgery, Aarhus University Hospital, Aarhus C, Denmark.
Childs Nerv Syst. 2011 Nov;27(11):1951-5. doi: 10.1007/s00381-011-1473-2. Epub 2011 May 7.
In Denmark, prevention to reduce the spina bifida birth rate has focused on two areas: folic acid supplementation (1997) and changes in the national ultrasonography screening programme (2004). Myelomeningocele (MMC) is the most severe malformation among the spina bifidas. Taking into consideration the potential negative effect of high-dose folic acid consumption, we found a need to look into the effectiveness of these two strategies in our complete MMC population.
All spina bifida patients born in the western part of Denmark are differentiated into proper subgroups based on MR imaging, giving us a unique chance to study a true MMC population. The total number of the group of MMC children since 1983 is 121. One hundred and eight (89%) parents answered a questionnaire.
Following the changes in the prenatal ultrasonography screening programme in 2004, a significant decline of 60% live birth MMC per year was noted, incidence rate ratio (IRR) = 40% (22-73%), p = 0.3%. We found no change in MMC birth rate after introduction of folic acid supplementation, IRR = 121% (81-181%), p = 36%.
Our findings demonstrate no effect of folic acid recommendation due to lack of compliance among women of reproductive age in Denmark. However, we found an improved early detection rate of prenatal MMC by high-quality ultrasonography. Subsequent early termination of pregnancy has led to a significant reduction of birth rate of babies with MMC.
在丹麦,预防脊柱裂出生率的降低主要集中在两个方面:叶酸补充(1997年)和国家超声筛查计划的改变(2004年)。脊髓脊膜膨出(MMC)是脊柱裂中最严重的畸形。考虑到高剂量叶酸摄入的潜在负面影响,我们认为有必要研究这两种策略在我们完整的MMC人群中的有效性。
丹麦西部出生的所有脊柱裂患者根据磁共振成像被分为适当的亚组,这使我们有独特的机会研究真正的MMC人群。自1983年以来,MMC儿童组的总数为121人。108名(89%)家长回答了一份问卷。
2004年产前超声筛查计划改变后,每年活产MMC显著下降60%,发病率比(IRR)=40%(22-73%),p=0.3%。我们发现补充叶酸后MMC出生率没有变化,IRR=121%(81-181%),p=36%。
我们的研究结果表明,由于丹麦育龄妇女缺乏依从性,叶酸推荐没有效果。然而,我们发现通过高质量超声检查可提高产前MMC的早期检测率。随后的早期终止妊娠导致MMC患儿出生率显著降低。