Welsch C, Welsch M, Huelskamp L, Gonzalez M, Vanderploeg L
Int J Oncol. 1995 Jan;6(1):55-64. doi: 10.3892/ijo.6.1.55.
The purpose of this study was to assess the effects of the type of dietary fat [corn oil (controls), olive oil, linseed oil, primrose oil, canola oil and fish (Menhaden) oil] and the amount of dietary fat on the growth of MDA-MB231 human breast carcinomas in female athymic nude mice. The different types of fats examined in these studies differ widely in their omega-3, -6 and -9 fatty acid contents, fatty acid chain length and their degree of unsaturation. These fats were fed to the carcinoma bearing mice at 20% of the diet by weight and for 5 to 8 weeks. No significant effect of these diets on mouse body weight gains throughout the study was observed. Compared to the corn oil controls, none of the dietary fats significantly affected the growth of the human breast carcinomas in these animals, with the exception of fish oil which consistently and significantly (P<0.05 to P<0.001) suppressed carcinoma growth. DNA synthesis of the human breast carcinomas derived from the fish oil fed mice was assessed by BrdU and PCNA labeling indices and by H-3-thymidine autoradiographic analysis. Despite the fact that the carcinomas derived from the fish oil fed mice were significantly smaller than the carcinomas from the corn oil fed mice, there were no significant differences in any of these parameters of DNA synthesis between the two groups (corn oil and fish oil) of carcinomas. In contrast, in the human breast carcinomas derived from the fish oil fed mice, a significant increase (P<0.01 to P<0.001) in the rate of (125)IUrd loss (K-L/day) and a significant increase (P<0.05 to P<0.001) in the cell loss factor (phi) (phi=1-T-P/T-D) was observed, compared to carcinomas derived from corn oil fed mice. Analysis of the human breast carcinomas for TBARS, a measure of secondary products of lipid peroxidation, revealed that the carcinomas derived from the fish oil fed mice had significantly increased (P<0.001) concentrations of these products compared to carcinomas derived from corn oil fed mice. These results provide evidence that the suppression of growth of human breast carcinoma MDA-MB231 in athymic nude mice by dietary fish oil appears to be due primarily to an increase in the loss of cells from the carcinomas in lieu of a suppression of DNA synthesis, a phenomenon that may be due to the increased concentration of lipid peroxidation products in the tumor tissue. In the studies designed to examine the effect of the amount of fat on growth of MDA-MB231 human breast carcinomas in athymic nude mice, one group of mice was fed a high fat diet (corn oil, 29%) and a second group of mice was fed a low fat diet (corn oil, 1.8%). Both diets were fed at a restricted level, i.e., 65% of ad libitum. A third group of mice was fed a high fat diet (corn oil, 18.1%) ad libitum. The diets were formulated to assure that mice of each group consumed equal amounts of protein, vitamins, minerals and fiber; mice fed the high fat diets (ad libitum and restricted) consumed equal amounts of fat. Growth of the human breast carcinomas in mice fed the high fat and low fat restricted diets was not significantly different despite the large difference in fat consumption. Growth of the carcinomas in mice fed the high fat diet ad libitum was substantially greater than carcinoma growth in mice fed the restricted high fat diet (P<0.001) despite equal amounts of fat consumption. These results demonstrate that in an environment of energy (caloric) restriction, high levels of dietary fat will not enhance growth of MDA-MB231 human breast carcinomas in athymic nude mice, thus emphasizing the important role for energy (calories) in the enhancement of mammary (breast) tumorigenic processes by high fat diets.
本研究的目的是评估膳食脂肪类型[玉米油(对照组)、橄榄油、亚麻籽油、月见草油、菜籽油和鱼油(鲱鱼油)]以及膳食脂肪量对雌性无胸腺裸鼠体内MDA - MB231人乳腺癌生长的影响。这些研究中所检测的不同类型脂肪在ω-3、-6和-9脂肪酸含量、脂肪酸链长度及其不饱和度方面差异很大。将这些脂肪按饮食重量的20%喂给荷癌小鼠,持续5至8周。在整个研究过程中,未观察到这些饮食对小鼠体重增加有显著影响。与玉米油对照组相比,除了鱼油能持续且显著地(P<0.05至P<0.001)抑制癌生长外,其他膳食脂肪均未对这些动物体内的人乳腺癌生长产生显著影响。通过BrdU和PCNA标记指数以及H-3-胸腺嘧啶放射自显影分析评估了来自喂食鱼油小鼠的人乳腺癌的DNA合成。尽管来自喂食鱼油小鼠的癌明显小于来自喂食玉米油小鼠的癌,但两组(玉米油组和鱼油组)癌的这些DNA合成参数均无显著差异。相反,与来自喂食玉米油小鼠的癌相比,在来自喂食鱼油小鼠的人乳腺癌中,观察到(125)IUrd损失率(K - L/天)显著增加(P<0.01至P<0.001),细胞损失因子(phi)(phi = 1 - T - P/T - D)也显著增加(P<0.05至P<0.001)。对人乳腺癌进行TBARS(脂质过氧化二级产物的一种测量指标)分析发现,与来自喂食玉米油小鼠的癌相比,来自喂食鱼油小鼠的癌中这些产物的浓度显著增加(P<0.001)。这些结果表明,膳食鱼油对无胸腺裸鼠体内人乳腺癌MDA - MB231生长的抑制作用似乎主要是由于癌中细胞损失增加,而非DNA合成受到抑制,这种现象可能是由于肿瘤组织中脂质过氧化产物浓度增加所致。在旨在研究脂肪量对无胸腺裸鼠体内MDA - MB231人乳腺癌生长影响的研究中,一组小鼠喂食高脂肪饮食(玉米油,29%),另一组小鼠喂食低脂肪饮食(玉米油,1.8%)。两种饮食均按限制水平喂食,即自由摄食量的65%。第三组小鼠自由摄食高脂肪饮食(玉米油,18.1%)。这些饮食的配方确保每组小鼠摄入等量的蛋白质、维生素、矿物质和纤维;喂食高脂肪饮食(自由摄食和限制摄食)的小鼠摄入等量的脂肪。尽管脂肪摄入量差异很大,但喂食高脂肪和低脂肪限制饮食的小鼠体内人乳腺癌的生长并无显著差异。自由摄食高脂肪饮食的小鼠体内癌的生长明显大于喂食限制高脂肪饮食的小鼠(P<0.001),尽管脂肪摄入量相同。这些结果表明,在能量(热量)限制的环境中,高水平的膳食脂肪不会促进无胸腺裸鼠体内MDA - MB231人乳腺癌的生长,从而强调了能量(热量)在高脂肪饮食增强乳腺(乳房)肿瘤发生过程中的重要作用。