Hospital for Orthopaedic Surgery Lovran, School of Medicine, University of Rijeka, Rijeka, Croatia.
Int Orthop. 2011 Oct;35(10):1523-8. doi: 10.1007/s00264-011-1256-0. Epub 2011 May 13.
The purpose of this study was to simplify and enhance the ultrasound (US) analysis of the infant's hip by introducing a novel parameter named "L value" into the widely used Graf method.
We analysed 508 ultrasonographic images of the hips in infants aged three months. The images were first evaluated using the Graf measurements. On the same images, two additional measurements were performed in order to define the new parameter that was named L value. The threshold values of the new L value were identified based on the highest specificity as well as sensitivity for discrimination between the Graf groups. Those values were then used in order to reclassify the hips into three simplified groups. Inter-observer agreement was estimated by Cohen's kappa coefficient.
The threshold values for the L value between Graf groups Ia and Ib was 0.46, between Ib and IIb was 0.68 and between IIb and IIc was 0.92. Correlation analysis between Graf's classification and the values of the L value was performed and was proved to be statistically significant, r = 0.49; p < 0.001. After simplifying the classification into three newly defined groups of patients depending on the degree of hip development, the correlation coefficient was much higher, r = 0.94, r (2) = 0.88 for p < 0.001. Inter-observer agreement for the L value was substantial.
The new L value parameter in Graf's ultrasound hip evaluation enables a faster, simpler, more reliable and more unbiased classification for developmental dysplasia of the hip as the L value changes proportionally with the hip maturity.
本研究旨在通过引入新参数“L 值”简化并改进 Graf 法中婴儿髋关节的超声(US)分析。
我们分析了 508 例三个月龄婴儿髋关节的超声图像。首先使用 Graf 测量值评估这些图像。在同一图像上,还进行了另外两个测量,以定义新的 L 值参数。根据新 L 值的最高特异性和灵敏度来确定区分 Graf 组的新阈值。然后使用这些值将髋关节重新分为三个简化组。采用 Cohen's kappa 系数评估观察者间的一致性。
L 值在 Graf 组 Ia 和 Ib 之间的阈值为 0.46,在 Ib 和 IIb 之间的阈值为 0.68,在 IIb 和 IIc 之间的阈值为 0.92。对 Graf 分类与 L 值之间进行相关性分析,结果证明具有统计学意义,r=0.49;p<0.001。根据髋关节发育程度将分类简化为三个新定义的患者组后,相关系数更高,r=0.94,r(2)=0.88,p<0.001。观察者间对 L 值的一致性很高。
Graf 髋关节超声评估中的新 L 值参数可实现更快、更简单、更可靠且更公正的髋关节发育不良分类,因为 L 值与髋关节成熟度成比例变化。