Naini Farhad B, Donaldson Ana Nora A, McDonald Fraser, Cobourne Martyn T
Kingston and St George's Hospitals and St George's Medical School, London, UK.
J Oral Maxillofac Surg. 2012 Jan;70(1):192-206. doi: 10.1016/j.joms.2010.12.055. Epub 2011 May 14.
The purpose of this investigation was to undertake an objective and quantitative evaluation of how severity of asymmetries affecting the mandible and chin point influence perceived attractiveness.
The mandible and chin point of idealized male and female frontal facial images were altered in 5-mm increments from 0 to 25 mm and to the left and right, to represent horizontal, vertical, and combined asymmetry affecting these regions. These images were rated on a 7-point Likert scale by a preselected group of orthognathic patients before treatment, clinicians, and laypeople.
In relation to a 5-mm asymmetry, observers progressively decreased attractiveness ratings and increased the desire for surgery for greater asymmetries. Clinicians and patients were found to be more critical than laypeople. The desire for surgery decreased by 3% for each year increase in age, was 53% less for men, and 45% greater for white observers.
Asymmetry of 10 mm is perceived as being significant; at 5 mm and below, it is largely unnoticed. The greater the degree of asymmetry greater than 10 mm, the more noticeable and the greater the desire was for correction. Clinician and patient ratings were similar and more critical than ratings of laypeople. A desire for surgery was negligible for 5 mm of asymmetry but increased considerably at 10 mm and continued to increase with greater degrees of asymmetry. The highest-rated images showed perfect bilateral symmetry, whereas the lowest-rated images showed significant degrees of mandibular and chin asymmetry.
本研究旨在对影响下颌骨和颏点的不对称严重程度如何影响感知吸引力进行客观定量评估。
将理想化的男性和女性正面面部图像的下颌骨和颏点以5毫米的增量从0改变到25毫米,并向左和向右改变,以表示影响这些区域的水平、垂直和组合不对称。这些图像由一组预先选定的正颌患者在治疗前、临床医生和外行人按照7分李克特量表进行评分。
与5毫米的不对称相比,观察者对更大不对称的吸引力评分逐渐降低,且进行手术的意愿增加。发现临床医生和患者比外行人更严格。手术意愿随年龄每增加一岁降低3%,男性降低53%,白人观察者增加45%。
10毫米的不对称被认为是显著的;5毫米及以下则基本未被注意到。大于10毫米的不对称程度越大,越明显,矫正的意愿也越大。临床医生和患者的评分相似,且比外行人的评分更严格。5毫米不对称时手术意愿可忽略不计,但在10毫米时显著增加,并随着不对称程度的增加而持续上升。评分最高的图像显示出完美的双侧对称,而评分最低的图像显示出明显的下颌骨和颏不对称。