Department of Vascular and Endovascular Surgery, Western Vascular Institute, University College Hospital, Galway, Ireland.
J Vasc Surg. 2011 Aug;54(2):440-6; discussion 446-7. doi: 10.1016/j.jvs.2011.02.057. Epub 2011 May 14.
Critical limb ischemia (CLI) patients who are unsuitable for intervention face the dire prospect of primary amputation. Sequential compression biomechanical device (SCBD) therapy provides a limb salvage option for these patients. This study assessed the outcome of SCBD in severe CLI patients who otherwise would face an amputation. Primary end points were limb salvage and 30-day mortality. Secondary end points were hemodynamic outcomes (increase in popliteal artery flow and toe pressure), ulcer healing, quality-adjusted time without symptoms of disease or toxicity of treatment (Q-TwiST), and cost-effectiveness.
From 2004 to 2009, we assessed 4538 patients with peripheral vascular disease (PVD). Of these, 707 had CLI, 518 underwent intervention, and 189 were not suitable for any intervention. A total of 171 patients joined the SCBD program for 3 months.
All patients were Rutherford category ≥4. Median follow-up was 13 months. Mean toe pressure increased from 39.9 to 55.42 mm Hg, with a mean difference in toe pressure of 15.49 mm Hg (P = .0001). Mean popliteal flow increased from 35.44 to 55.91 cm/s, with mean difference in popliteal flow of 20.47 cm/s (P < .0001). Mortality at 30 days was 0.6%. Median amputation-free survival was 18 months. Limb salvage at 3.5 years was 94%. Freedom from major adverse clinical events (MACE) at 4.5 years was 62.5%. We treated 171 patients with SCBD at a cost of €681,948, with an estimated median per-patient cost of treatment with SCBD of €3988.
SCBD therapy is a cost-effective and clinically efficacious solution in CLI patients with no option of revascularization. It provides adequate limb salvage and ameliorated amputation-free survival while providing relief of rest pain without any intervention.
不适合介入治疗的严重肢体缺血(CLI)患者面临着初次截肢的可怕前景。连续压缩生物力学装置(SCBD)治疗为这些患者提供了一种肢体保全选择。本研究评估了否则需要截肢的严重 CLI 患者接受 SCBD 治疗的结果。主要终点是肢体保全和 30 天死亡率。次要终点是血流动力学结果(增加腘动脉流量和趾压)、溃疡愈合、无疾病症状或治疗毒性的质量调整时间(Q-TwiST)和成本效益。
2004 年至 2009 年,我们评估了 4538 例外周血管疾病(PVD)患者。其中,707 例患有 CLI,518 例行介入治疗,189 例不适合任何介入治疗。共有 171 例患者参加了 3 个月的 SCBD 计划。
所有患者均为 Rutherford 分级≥4 级。中位随访时间为 13 个月。平均趾压从 39.9 升至 55.42mmHg,趾压平均差值为 15.49mmHg(P=0.0001)。平均腘动脉流量从 35.44 增加到 55.91cm/s,腘动脉流量平均差值为 20.47cm/s(P<0.0001)。30 天死亡率为 0.6%。中位无截肢生存率为 18 个月。3.5 年时的肢体保全率为 94%。4.5 年时免于主要不良临床事件(MACE)的比例为 62.5%。我们用 SCBD 治疗了 171 例患者,费用为 681948 欧元,估计每位患者的 SCBD 治疗费用中位数为 3988 欧元。
在没有血运重建选择的 CLI 患者中,SCBD 治疗是一种具有成本效益且临床有效的治疗方法。它提供了足够的肢体保全和改善的无截肢生存率,同时在无需任何干预的情况下缓解静息痛。