Navi Daniel, Riaz Nadeem, Levin Yakir S, Sullivan Naomi C, Kim Youn H, Hoppe Richard T
Department of Dermatology, Stanford University, Stanford, CA, USA.
Arch Dermatol. 2011 May;147(5):561-7. doi: 10.1001/archdermatol.2011.98.
To review the Stanford University experience with total skin electron-beam therapy (TSEBT) of 30 Gy or greater as monotherapy in patients with mycosis fungoides (MF) and compare with subgroups receiving adjuvant nitrogen mustard (HN2), and further update our experience with repeated courses of TSEBT.
Retrospective study.
Academic referral center, multidisciplinary clinic.
A total of 180 patients with MF treated from 1970 through 2007 with T2 MF (103 with generalized patch or plaque disease) or T3 MF (77 with tumor disease). Patients with extracutaneous disease were excluded.
Total skin electron-beam therapy with or without adjuvant topical HN2.
Clinical response rate, freedom from relapse (FFR), overall survival (OS), and progression-free survival (PFS) after TSEBT.
The overall response rate (ORR) was 100%; 60% of patients achieved a complete clinical response (patients with T2 MF = 75%, those with T3 MF = 47%). The 5- and 10-year OS rates of the entire cohort were 59% and 40%, respectively. There were no significant differences in FFR (P = .30 for T2 disease; P = .50 for T3 disease), PFS (P = .10 for T2 disease; P = .40 for T3 disease), or OS (P = .30 for T2 disease; P = .50 for T3 disease) between adjuvant HN2 and TSEBT monotherapy cohorts. The ORR was 100% in patients receiving a second course of TSEBT with median FFR of 6 months.
A TSEBT of 30 Gy or greater is highly effective in treating T2-T3 MF, with better outcomes in T2 disease. There was no clinical advantage to adjuvant HN2 as used in our cohort. Second courses of TSEBT are safe and efficacious and provide clinically meaningful palliation for select patients.
回顾斯坦福大学采用30 Gy及以上的全身皮肤电子束治疗(TSEBT)作为蕈样肉芽肿(MF)患者单一疗法的经验,并与接受辅助性氮芥(HN2)治疗的亚组进行比较,进一步更新我们重复进行TSEBT疗程的经验。
回顾性研究。
学术转诊中心,多学科诊所。
1970年至2007年期间共180例MF患者接受了T2期MF(103例为泛发性斑片或斑块病)或T3期MF(77例为肿瘤病)治疗。排除有皮肤外疾病的患者。
采用或不采用辅助性外用HN2的全身皮肤电子束治疗。
TSEBT后的临床缓解率、无复发生存率(FFR)、总生存率(OS)和无进展生存率(PFS)。
总缓解率(ORR)为100%;60%的患者实现了完全临床缓解(T2期MF患者为75%,T3期MF患者为47%)。整个队列的5年和10年OS率分别为59%和40%。辅助性HN2和TSEBT单一疗法队列在FFR(T2期疾病P = 0.30;T3期疾病P = 0.50)、PFS(T2期疾病P = 0.10;T3期疾病P = 0.40)或OS(T2期疾病P = 0.30;T3期疾病P = 0.50)方面无显著差异。接受第二疗程TSEBT的患者ORR为100%,中位FFR为6个月。
30 Gy及以上的TSEBT在治疗T2 - T3期MF方面非常有效,T2期疾病的疗效更佳。在我们的队列中,辅助性HN2没有临床优势。TSEBT的第二疗程安全有效,可为部分患者提供有临床意义的缓解。