García-Pérez Lidia, Serrano-Aguilar Pedro
Fundación Canaria de Investigación y Salud (FUNCIS), Spain.
Curr Clin Pharmacol. 2011 May;6(2):115-24. doi: 10.2174/157488411796151147.
It was conducted a systematic review of economic evaluations that assessed the cost-effectiveness of interventions to enhance the medication adherence in psychiatric patients. Several bibliographic databases were searched: MEDLINE, MEDLINE in process, PSYCINFO, EMBASE, Cochrane Controlled Trials Register, CINAHL, CRD, EconLit, Science Citation Index and Social Science Citation Index. Full economic evaluations which assessed interventions to enhance the adherence to drug therapy in adult patients with a mental illness were included. Data were extracted and the methodological quality of selected studies was assessed. The information was synthesized through narrative procedures. Four clinical trials and two ongoing studies fulfilled the selection criteria. Two studies did not find significant differences in adherence between the interventions (a compliance-enhancing program, a therapeutic drug monitoring and a pharmacy-based intervention) and the control groups; one study found that a compliance program was more effective than a non-specific counselling intervention over 18 months in psychotic patients; another study found better results in terms of adherence among high-severity depressed patients receiving a stepped collaborative care during 12 months in comparison to a control group; in moderate-severity patients the differences disappeared after the first 6 months. None of the four studies found significant differences in costs between groups because of the low statistical power. In summary, adherence enhancing programs could be cost-effective in psychiatric patients although this statement is based on few studies with limited methodological quality. It is necessary more and better research on the cost-effectiveness of interventions in the field of mental health.
对评估提高精神病患者药物依从性干预措施成本效益的经济评估进行了系统评价。检索了多个书目数据库:MEDLINE、MEDLINE正在进行中、PSYCINFO、EMBASE、Cochrane对照试验注册库、CINAHL、CRD、EconLit、科学引文索引和社会科学引文索引。纳入了评估提高成年精神病患者药物治疗依从性干预措施的全面经济评估。提取数据并评估所选研究的方法学质量。通过叙述性程序对信息进行综合。四项临床试验和两项正在进行的研究符合选择标准。两项研究未发现干预措施(一项提高依从性计划、一项治疗药物监测和一项基于药房的干预措施)与对照组之间在依从性方面存在显著差异;一项研究发现,在18个月内,一项依从性计划对精神病患者比非特异性咨询干预更有效;另一项研究发现,与对照组相比,接受12个月阶梯式协作护理的重度抑郁症患者在依从性方面有更好的结果;在中度严重程度患者中,前6个月后差异消失。由于统计效力较低,四项研究均未发现组间成本存在显著差异。总之,提高依从性计划对精神病患者可能具有成本效益,尽管这一说法基于方法学质量有限的少数研究。有必要对心理健康领域干预措施的成本效益进行更多更好的研究。