Center for the Study of Society, University of Haifa, Mount Carmel, Haifa, Israel.
J Interpers Violence. 2011 Dec;26(18):3599-617. doi: 10.1177/0886260511403750. Epub 2011 May 20.
This study addresses the intended escalatory tendency in eight hypothetical situations in which the provocator's identity (partner or stranger, male or female) and the provocation form (verbal or physical aggression) were manipulated. The research question is "how does the identity of the provocator and the form of his or her provocation affect the participant's intended escalation level, and does the gender of the participant affect differences in intended escalation level?" The research sample consisted of 208 Israeli couples. The main finding is that women's intended response to their male partner is more escalatory than men's intended response to their female partner. Results also show that women's escalation is the most severe to partner provocation and the least severe to male strangers' provocation. Men's escalation is the most severe to provocation by male strangers and the least severe to their partner's provocation. Findings indicate that men's intention to escalate decreases as their partner's provocation becomes more severe. The severity of provocation has little effect on women's inten-tion to escalate. Such results are consistent with social role theory and sexual selection theory that maintain that status enhancement is more important for men than for women, and is more important for men than risk reduction is, whereas the opposite is true for women.
本研究探讨了在八种假设情境中挑衅者身份(伴侣或陌生人、男性或女性)和挑衅形式(言语或身体攻击)被操纵时,预期的升级趋势。研究问题是“挑衅者的身份和挑衅形式如何影响参与者的预期升级水平,参与者的性别是否会影响预期升级水平的差异?”研究样本由 208 对以色列夫妇组成。主要发现是,女性对其男性伴侣的反应比男性对其女性伴侣的反应更具升级性。研究结果还表明,女性的升级对伴侣的挑衅最为严重,对男性陌生人的挑衅最为轻微。男性的升级对男性陌生人的挑衅最为严重,对其伴侣的挑衅最为轻微。研究结果表明,随着伴侣挑衅的加剧,男性升级的意图会降低。挑衅的严重程度对女性升级的意图影响不大。这些结果与社会角色理论和性选择理论一致,这些理论认为,地位提升对男性比对女性更重要,对男性比对风险降低更重要,而对女性则相反。