Maher Sara, Creighton Doug, Kondratek Melodie, Krauss John, Qu Xianggui
Program in Physical Therapy, Oakland University, USA.
J Man Manip Ther. 2010 Mar;18(1):29-36. doi: 10.1179/106698110X12595770849560.
The purpose of this case series was to explore the effects of tibio-femoral (TF) manual traction on pain and passive range of motion (PROM) in individuals with unilateral motion impairment and pain in knee flexion. Thirteen participants volunteered for the study. All participants received 6 minutes of TF traction mobilization applied at end-range passive knee flexion. PROM measurements were taken before the intervention and after 2, 4, and 6 minutes of TF joint traction. Pain was measured using a visual analog scale with the TF joint at rest, at end-range passive knee flexion, during the application of joint traction, and immediately post-treatment. There were significant differences in PROM after 2 and 4 minutes of traction, with no significance noted after 4 minutes. A significant change in knee flexion of 25.9°, which exceeded the MDC(95,) was found when comparing PROM measurements pre- to final intervention. While pain did not change significantly over time, pain levels did change significantly during each treatment session. Pain significantly increased when the participant's knee was passively flexed to end range; it was reduced, although not significantly, during traction mobilization; and it significantly decreased following traction. This case series supports TF joint traction as a means of stretching shortened articular and periarticular tissues without increasing reported levels of pain during or after treatment. In addition, this is the first study documenting the temporal aspects of treatment effectiveness in motion restoration.
本病例系列研究的目的是探讨胫股(TF)手法牵引对单侧膝关节活动受限并伴有屈膝疼痛患者的疼痛及被动活动范围(PROM)的影响。13名参与者自愿参加了该研究。所有参与者均在膝关节被动屈曲终末位接受6分钟的TF牵引松动治疗。在干预前以及TF关节牵引2分钟、4分钟和6分钟后测量PROM。使用视觉模拟量表在TF关节静止时、膝关节被动屈曲终末位、关节牵引过程中以及治疗后立即测量疼痛程度。牵引2分钟和4分钟后PROM有显著差异,4分钟后无显著差异。在比较干预前与最终干预后的PROM测量值时,发现膝关节屈曲有25.9°的显著变化,超过了最小可检测变化值(MDC,95%)。虽然疼痛程度随时间未发生显著变化,但在每次治疗过程中疼痛水平有显著改变。当参与者的膝关节被动屈曲至终末位时疼痛显著增加;在牵引松动过程中疼痛有所减轻,但不显著;牵引后疼痛显著降低。本病例系列研究支持TF关节牵引可作为一种拉伸缩短的关节及关节周围组织的方法,且不会增加治疗期间或治疗后报告的疼痛水平。此外,这是第一项记录运动恢复中治疗效果时间方面的研究。