Dey A K, Mann D D
Department of Biosystems Engineering, University of Manitoba, Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada.
J Agric Saf Health. 2011 Apr;17(2):91-110. doi: 10.13031/2013.36495.
Agricultural spraying involves two major tasks: guiding a sprayer in response to a GPS navigation device, and simultaneous monitoring of rear-attached booms under various illumination and terrain difficulty levels. The aim of the present study was to investigate the effect of illumination, task difficulty, and task level on the mental workload of an individual operating an agricultural sprayer in response to a commercial GPS lightbar, and to explore the sensitivity of the NASA-TLX and SSWAT subjective rating scales in discriminating the subjective experienced workload under various task, illumination, and difficulty levels. Mental workload was measured using performance measures (lateral root mean square error and reaction time), physiological measures (0.1 Hz power of HRV, latency of the P300 component of event-related potential, and eye-glance behavior), and two subjective rating scales (NASA-TLX and SSWAT). Sixteen male university students participated in this experiment, and a fixed-base high-fidelity agricultural tractor simulator was used to create a simulated spraying task. All performance measures, the P300 latency, and subjective rating scales showed a common trend that mental workload increased with the change in illumination from day to night, with task difficulty from low to high, and with task type from single to dual. The 0.1 Hz power of HRV contradicted the performance measures. Eye-glance data showed that under night illumination, participants spent more time looking at the lightbar for guidance information. A similar trend was observed with the change in task type from single to dual. Both subjective rating scales showed a common trend of increasing mental workload with the change in illumination, difficulty, and task levels. However, the SSWAT scale was more sensitive than the NASA-TLX scale. With the change in illumination, difficulty, and task levels, participants spent more mental resources to meet the increased task demand; hence, the illumination, task difficulty, and task level affected the mental workload of an agricultural sprayer operator operating a sprayer in response to a GPS lightbar.
根据全球定位系统(GPS)导航设备引导喷雾器,以及在不同光照和地形难度水平下同时监测后附式喷杆。本研究的目的是调查光照、任务难度和任务水平对响应商用GPS光条操作农业喷雾器的个人心理负荷的影响,并探索美国国家航空航天局任务负荷指数(NASA-TLX)和简易主观工作负荷评估工具(SSWAT)主观评分量表在区分不同任务、光照和难度水平下主观体验到的工作负荷方面的敏感性。使用绩效指标(横向均方根误差和反应时间)、生理指标(心率变异性的0.1赫兹功率、事件相关电位P300成分的潜伏期和目光扫视行为)以及两个主观评分量表(NASA-TLX和SSWAT)来测量心理负荷。16名男性大学生参与了本实验,并使用固定基座高保真农用拖拉机模拟器创建模拟喷洒任务。所有绩效指标、P300潜伏期和主观评分量表都呈现出一个共同趋势,即随着光照从白天到夜晚的变化、任务难度从低到高的变化以及任务类型从单一到双重的变化,心理负荷增加。心率变异性的0.1赫兹功率与绩效指标相反。目光扫视数据显示,在夜间光照条件下,参与者花费更多时间查看光条以获取引导信息。随着任务类型从单一变为双重,也观察到了类似趋势。两个主观评分量表都呈现出随着光照、难度和任务水平的变化心理负荷增加的共同趋势。然而,SSWAT量表比NASA-TLX量表更敏感。随着光照、难度和任务水平的变化,参与者花费更多心理资源来满足增加的任务需求;因此,光照、任务难度和任务水平会影响响应GPS光条操作喷雾器的农业喷雾器操作员的心理负荷。