Stallergenes GmbH, Medical Department, Kamp-Lintfort, Germany.
Ann Med. 2011;43(6):418-24. doi: 10.3109/07853890.2011.595426. Epub 2011 Jun 17.
Abstract Background. Despite strong evidence for subcutaneous and sublingual immunotherapy for the treatment of allergic rhinoconjunctivitis, comparative data are scarce. Objectives. We performed an individual patient data meta-analysis of four observational studies to compare the effectiveness of both application routes. Methods. After individual analysis, a subsequent analysis of the total data pool was performed. Descriptive and explorative data analysis methods were used. Results. Altogether 847 patients (382 male, 453 female) aged 3-78 years (mean age 28.3 years) were treated with specific immunotherapy: 665 (78.5%) patients sublingual and 182 (21.5%) subcutaneous. The majority of patients (61.6%) in both treatment groups started specific immunotherapy due to severe rhinitis symptoms which occurred frequently or very frequently. Most patients in both treatment groups had moderate to severe conjunctivitis symptom load which occurred frequently or very frequently. Median rhinitis and conjunctivitis symptom loads decreased during both treatments to the same extent. Similar improvements in the symptom loads were observed in patients stratified for age, disease duration, and presence or absence of mild to moderate asthma. Conclusion. The effectiveness of sublingual and subcutaneous immunotherapy with pollen extracts appeared virtually equal in daily medical routine. Due to the advantageous safety profile, the sublingual application may be favorable.
摘要背景。尽管有强有力的证据表明皮下和舌下免疫疗法可治疗过敏性鼻结膜炎,但比较数据仍然缺乏。目的。我们对四项观察性研究进行了个体患者数据荟萃分析,以比较两种应用途径的有效性。方法。在进行个体分析后,我们对总数据池进行了后续分析。采用描述性和探索性数据分析方法。结果。共有 847 名年龄在 3-78 岁(平均年龄 28.3 岁)的患者接受了特异性免疫治疗:665 名(78.5%)患者接受舌下免疫治疗,182 名(21.5%)患者接受皮下免疫治疗。两组治疗中,大多数患者(61.6%)因频繁或非常频繁发生的严重鼻炎症状而开始接受特异性免疫治疗。两组患者中大多数人都有中度至重度结膜炎症状负担,这些症状频繁或非常频繁发生。在两种治疗中,鼻炎和结膜炎症状负担都以相同的程度降低。在年龄、疾病持续时间、是否存在轻度至中度哮喘的分层患者中,观察到类似的症状负荷改善。结论。花粉提取物的舌下和皮下免疫疗法的有效性在日常医疗实践中似乎基本相等。由于具有有利的安全性特征,舌下应用可能更具优势。