Memorial University of Newfoundland, Institute for Social & Economic Research, Arts and Administration Building, St. John's, NL A1C 5S7, Canada.
Soc Sci Med. 2011 Jul;73(2):301-7. doi: 10.1016/j.socscimed.2011.05.022. Epub 2011 Jun 1.
Recently, public health agents and the popular media have argued that rising levels of obesity are due, in part, to "obesogenic" environments, and in particular to the clustering of fast food establishments in Western urban centers that are poor and working class. Our findings from a multi-site, cross-national qualitative study of teenaged Canadians' eating practices in urban and rural areas offer another perspective on this topic, showing that fast food consumption is not simply a function of the location of fast food outlets, and that Canadian teens engage in complex ways with the varied dimensions of choosing (or rejecting) fast foods. Drawing on evidence gleaned from semi-structured interviews with 132 teenagers (77 girls and 55 boys, ages 13-19 years) carried out between 2007 and 2009, we maintain that no easy relationship exists between the geographical availability of fast food and teen eating behaviors. We use critical obesity literature that challenges widely accepted understandings about obesity prevalence and etiology, as well as Lamont's (1992, 2000) concept of "moral boundary work," to argue that teen fast food consumption and avoidance is multifaceted and does not stem exclusively nor directly from spatial proximity or social class. Through moral boundary work, in which teens negotiated with moralistic notions of healthy eating, participants made and re-made themselves as "good" and successful subjects by Othering those who were "bad" in references to socially derived discourses of healthy eating.
最近,公共卫生机构和大众媒体认为,肥胖率的上升部分是由于“致肥胖环境”造成的,尤其是在西方城市中心贫困和工人阶级聚居区快餐店的集中。我们对加拿大青少年在城市和农村地区饮食行为的多地点、跨国定性研究的结果为这个话题提供了另一个视角,表明快餐消费不仅仅是快餐店位置的函数,而且加拿大青少年以复杂的方式参与选择(或拒绝)快餐的各种维度。我们利用 2007 年至 2009 年期间对 132 名青少年(77 名女孩和 55 名男孩,年龄 13-19 岁)进行的半结构化访谈中收集的证据,我们认为,快餐的地理可获得性与青少年的饮食行为之间不存在简单的关系。我们使用了具有批判性的肥胖文献,这些文献挑战了关于肥胖流行和病因的广泛接受的理解,以及拉蒙特(1992 年,2000 年)的“道德边界工作”概念,来论证青少年对快餐的消费和回避是多方面的,不仅仅直接源自空间接近度或社会阶层。通过道德边界工作,青少年用健康饮食的道德观念进行协商,参与者通过将那些在健康饮食的社会话语中被视为“不好”的人他者化,将自己塑造和再塑造为“好”和成功的主体。