Sensorimotor Neuroscience Laboratory, McMaster University, Hamilton, ON, Canada.
Neuropsychologia. 2011 Aug;49(10):2941-6. doi: 10.1016/j.neuropsychologia.2011.06.023. Epub 2011 Jun 29.
Forward models, generated from the efference copies of motor commands, are thought to monitor the accuracy of ongoing movement. By comparing predicted with actual afferent information, forward models also aid in the differentiation of self-produced movements from externally generated ones. Many have proposed that a consequence of this comparison is attenuation of the predicted component of incoming sensory signals. Previous work from our laboratory has shown that following the removal of an external visual reference, discrete sequential forces exceed target values. Forces produced at the fingertip were perceived as weaker, which lead to a systematic, compensatory over-production of the magnitudes required. The relatively new repetitive TMS protocol of continuous theta-burst stimulation (cTBS) has been shown to reliably depress cortical excitability for a period following stimulation. If sensory attenuation mechanisms were responsible for the overproduction of forces found in our previous results, we hypothesized that reducing cortical excitability of M1 through application of cTBS would induce discrepancy between the efference copy generated and motor output produced. As a result, we expected the overproduction of forces following visual feedback removal would be reduced after receiving cTBS. Participants produced series of pinch grip forces in time to a metronome and to visually specified force magnitudes. Visual feedback of force output was extinguished 10s into experimental trials and participants performed continued responses for the remaining 10s. Results confirmed our hypothesis. Mean peak force and constant error were greater and more positive in the absence of visual feedback regardless of stimulation condition; however, the magnitude of increase was significantly reduced following cTBS compared with baseline and sham conditions. Variability was not differentially affected by stimulation condition, increasing only with removal of visual feedback contingent upon the larger forces produced in these trials. Our findings provide further evidence to support the idea that TBS may differentially affect motor output and efference copy generation.
前向模型是由运动指令的传出副本生成的,被认为可以监测运动的准确性。通过比较预测的和实际传入的信息,前向模型还有助于区分自主产生的运动和外部产生的运动。许多人提出,这种比较的结果是传入感觉信号的预测成分减弱。我们实验室之前的工作表明,在去除外部视觉参考后,离散顺序力超过目标值。指尖产生的力被感知为较弱,这导致了所需幅度的系统、补偿性过度产生。相对较新的重复经颅磁刺激(rTMS)连续 theta 爆发刺激(cTBS)方案已被证明可以在刺激后可靠地降低皮质兴奋性一段时间。如果感觉衰减机制是导致我们之前的结果中力过度产生的原因,我们假设通过应用 cTBS 降低 M1 的皮质兴奋性会导致生成的传出副本与产生的运动输出之间出现差异。因此,我们预计在视觉反馈消除后接受 cTBS 会减少力的过度产生。参与者在节拍器的时间和视觉指定的力幅度下产生一系列捏夹力。在实验试验进行到 10 秒时,力输出的视觉反馈被熄灭,参与者在剩余的 10 秒内继续做出反应。结果证实了我们的假设。在没有视觉反馈的情况下,峰值力和恒定误差无论刺激条件如何都更大且更正向;然而,与基线和假刺激条件相比,在接受 cTBS 后,力的增加幅度显著降低。刺激条件对变异性没有差异影响,仅在这些试验中产生的力较大时才随视觉反馈的去除而增加。我们的发现提供了进一步的证据,支持 TBS 可能会以不同的方式影响运动输出和传出副本生成的观点。