Department of Otorhinolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery, Academic Medical Centre (AMC), Amsterdam, the Netherlands.
Rhinology. 2011 Jun;49(2):195-201. doi: 10.4193/Rhino10.153.
To assess the effectiveness and factors associated with restenosis after Draf type III (Endoscopic Modified Lothrop) frontal sinus drainage procedure.
Retrospective analysis of prospectively collected data.
A hundred and twenty two consecutive patients undergoing Draf III procedure for recalcitrant chronic frontal rhinosinusitis (CRS) (71%), frontal sinus mucocoele (15%), benign frontal sinus tumours (9%) and cystic fibrosis with severe CRS (5%) were followed up for an average of 33 months.
Symptom burden (Visual Analogue Scale and Rhinosinusitis Outcome Measure), patency of neo-ostium and revision surgery.
At the end of follow up, ninety percent of patients had a patent neo-ostium, while 88% were either clinically better or completely asymptomatic. Thirty-nine patients required endoscopic revision surgery and 9 eventually underwent frontal sinus obliteration. Sixty percent of revision operations were performed during the first two years. RSOM showed a significant improvement in both general and nasal symptoms while on a VAS, headache improved significantly. The only factor weakly associated with re-stenosis was the presence of allergy. There were no major complications during any of the procedures.
Draf III Procedure is safe and effective for patients who have failed conventional frontal sinus procedures and a valid alternative to frontal sinus obliteration. Although the revision rate may appear to be quite significant, it can often be performed as an outpatient procedure and needs to be balanced against the reduced morbidity and the ease of follow-up.
评估 Draf III 型(内镜改良 Lothrop)额窦引流术后再狭窄的效果及其相关因素。
前瞻性收集数据的回顾性分析。
122 例连续接受 Draf III 手术治疗难治性慢性额窦炎(CRS)(71%)、额窦黏液囊肿(15%)、良性额窦肿瘤(9%)和伴有严重 CRS 的囊性纤维化(5%)的患者,平均随访 33 个月。
症状负担(视觉模拟评分和鼻-鼻窦炎结局测量)、新窦口通畅性和修正手术。
随访结束时,90%的患者新窦口通畅,88%的患者临床状况改善或完全无症状。39 例患者需要内镜修正手术,9 例最终行额窦填塞。60%的修正手术在头两年内进行。RSOM 在一般症状和鼻部症状方面均有显著改善,而在 VAS 上,头痛显著改善。唯一与再狭窄相关的弱因素是过敏的存在。在任何手术过程中均无重大并发症。
Draf III 手术对于传统额窦手术失败的患者是安全有效的,是额窦填塞的有效替代方法。尽管修正率似乎相当高,但它通常可以作为门诊手术进行,需要权衡减少的发病率和便于随访。