Alicandri-Ciufelli Matteo, Cantaffa Carla, Basso Margherita, Colacurcio Vito, Marchioni Daniele, Lucidi Daniela
Department of Otolaryngology Head and Neck Surgery, University Hospital of Modena, 41121 Modena, Italy.
J Pers Med. 2024 Sep 9;14(9):951. doi: 10.3390/jpm14090951.
: The DRAF III procedure is indicated for the treatment of benign and selected malignant frontal sinus pathology. Several attempts have been made to find an intra or pre-operative measurement that was predictive of the feasibility of this operation and its success. Among those, the frontal sinus outflow tract anteroposterior diameter (FOAP) appears to be the one with the highest applicability in clinical practice, since it is easy to measure on pre-operative CT scan. The objective of the study is to evaluate whether the minimum and maximum frontal sinus outflow anteroposterior diameters (FOAP min and FOAP max) are associated with the risk of failure and consequently with the need for surgical revision. Secondly, we ought to evaluate whether the angle between the glabella and the nasion on the sagittal plane could influence surgical outcome. : This is a retrospective study on patients who underwent DRAF III for benign pathologies at a tertiary Italian referral center from January 2000 to July 2022. FOAP min and FOAP max were measured on the mid-sagittal sections of a pre-operative CT scan. The glabella-nasion angle (G-N angle) was calculated on the same sagittal section. These measurements were compared between patients who experienced a recurrence and those who did not. If a post-operative CT scan was available, the obtained anteroposterior diameter (OD) of the frontal sinus neo-ostium was also measured on the same section. A correlation analysis was performed between the three pre-operative radiologic parameters and OD. : Twenty-nine patients were included in the study. Six patients experienced restenosis requiring surgical revision. The median FOAP max resulted significantly higher in patients who did not experience recurrence (median: 14.8 mm, IQR: 3.84) than in patients who experienced a recurrence (median: 11.9 mm, IQR: 1.14) ( = 0.04). The FOAP max also showed a good positive correlation with OD ( = 0.0001; r = 0.7). The correlation between FOAP min and OD was not statistically significant, nor was a correlation found between FOAP min and recurrence risk. The G-N angle was not significantly different in patients who experienced recurrence and those who did not, nor did it show a correlation with OD. : The FOAP max might be a valid pre-operative radiologic parameter to guide a surgeon's approach to a DRAF III procedure, as it is easy to measure, shows a good correlation with OD, and seems to influence the risk of recurrence.
DRAF III手术适用于治疗良性及特定的恶性额窦病变。人们已多次尝试寻找能够预测该手术可行性及其成功与否的术中或术前测量指标。其中,额窦流出道前后径(FOAP)在临床实践中似乎是适用性最高的指标,因为它易于在术前CT扫描上测量。本研究的目的是评估额窦流出道最小和最大前后径(FOAP min和FOAP max)是否与手术失败风险相关,进而是否与手术翻修的必要性相关。其次,我们要评估在矢状面上眉间与鼻根之间的角度是否会影响手术结果。
这是一项对2000年1月至2022年7月期间在意大利一家三级转诊中心因良性病变接受DRAF III手术的患者进行的回顾性研究。FOAP min和FOAP max在术前CT扫描的正中矢状面上测量。眉间 - 鼻根角(G - N角)在同一矢状面上计算。对复发患者和未复发患者的这些测量值进行比较。如果有术后CT扫描,还在同一层面测量额窦新开口获得的前后径(OD)。对三个术前放射学参数与OD进行相关性分析。
本研究纳入了29例患者。6例患者出现再狭窄需要手术翻修。未复发患者的FOAP max中位数(中位数:14.8 mm,四分位距:3.84)显著高于复发患者(中位数:11.9 mm,四分位距:1.14)(P = 0.04)。FOAP max与OD也显示出良好的正相关性(P = 0.0001;r = 0.7)。FOAP min与OD之间的相关性无统计学意义,FOAP min与复发风险之间也未发现相关性。复发患者和未复发患者的G - N角无显著差异,且与OD也无相关性。
FOAP max可能是一个有效的术前放射学参数,可指导外科医生进行DRAF III手术,因为它易于测量,与OD显示出良好的相关性,且似乎会影响复发风险。