Department of Medicine, University of Alabama at Birmingham, USA.
Ethn Dis. 2011 Spring;21(2):223-9.
Racial/ethnic discrimination has adverse effects on health outcomes, as does low income and education, but the relationship between discrimination, income, and education is not well characterized. In this study, we describe the associations of discrimination with income and education in elderly African Americans (AA) and European Americans (EA).
Cross-sectional observational study involving computer-assisted telephone survey.
Southeastern United States.
AA and EA Medicare managed care enrollees.
Discrimination was measured with the Experience of Discrimination (EOD) scale (range 0-35). We used zero-inflated negative binomial models to determine the association between self-reported income and education and 1) presence of any discrimination and 2) intensity of discrimination.
Among 1,800 participants (45% AA, 56% female, and mean age 73 years), EA reported less discrimination than AA (4% vs. 47%; P < .001). AA men reported more discrimination and more intense discrimination than AA women (EOD scores 4.35 vs. 2.50; P < .001). Both income and education were directly and linearly associated with both presence of discrimination and intensity of discrimination in AA, so that people with higher incomes and education experienced more discrimination. In adjusted models, predicted EOD scores among AA decreased with increasing age categories (3.42, 3.21, 2.99, 2.53; P < .01) and increased with increasing income (2.36, 3.44, 4.17; P < .001) and education categories (2.31, 3.09, 5.12; P < .001).
This study suggests future research should focus less on differences between racial/ethnic groups and more on factors within minority populations that may contribute to healthcare disparities.
种族/民族歧视和低收入及低教育水平都会对健康结果产生不良影响,但歧视、收入和教育之间的关系尚未得到充分描述。在本研究中,我们描述了在老年非裔美国人(AA)和欧洲裔美国人(EA)中,歧视与收入和教育的关系。
涉及计算机辅助电话调查的横断面观察性研究。
美国东南部。
接受医疗保险管理式医疗的 AA 和 EA 参保者。
歧视程度采用歧视经历量表(EOD)进行评估(范围 0-35)。我们使用零膨胀负二项回归模型来确定报告的收入和教育与 1)存在任何歧视和 2)歧视严重程度之间的关系。
在 1800 名参与者中(45%为 AA,56%为女性,平均年龄为 73 岁),EA 报告的歧视程度低于 AA(4%比 47%;P<0.001)。AA 男性报告的歧视和歧视严重程度均高于 AA 女性(EOD 评分 4.35 比 2.50;P<0.001)。在 AA 中,收入和教育均与歧视的存在和严重程度呈直接和线性关系,因此收入和教育水平较高的人群经历的歧视更多。在调整后的模型中,AA 组的预测 EOD 评分随年龄组的增加而降低(3.42、3.21、2.99、2.53;P<0.01),随收入(2.36、3.44、4.17;P<0.001)和教育水平(2.31、3.09、5.12;P<0.001)的增加而增加。
本研究表明,未来的研究应较少关注种族/民族群体之间的差异,而更多地关注少数族裔群体内部可能导致医疗保健差异的因素。