Institute for Social Marketing, University of Stirling, Stirling FK9 4LA, Scotland, UK.
Tob Control. 2011 Sep;20(5):367-73. doi: 10.1136/tc.2011.042911. Epub 2011 Jul 12.
To explore the impact, if any, that using plain (non-branded) cigarette packs in real-life settings has on young adult smokers.
Naturalistic-type research was employed, where smokers used brown 'plain' packs for 2 weeks and their regular packs for 2 weeks, in real-life settings. Participants were recruited in Glasgow, Scotland. Of the 140 smokers aged 18-35 years who participated in the naturalistic study, 48 correctly completed and returned all questionnaires. Over the 4-week study period, participants completed a questionnaire twice a week assessing pack perceptions and feelings, feelings about smoking, salience of health warnings and smoking-related behaviours. A subsample of 18 participated in a post-study interview, which employed a semistructured topic guide to assess perceptions and experiences of using plain packs.
Trends in the data show that in comparison with branded packaging, plain packaging increased negative perceptions and feelings about the pack and about smoking. Plain packaging also increased avoidant behaviour (hiding the pack, covering the pack), certain smoking cessation behaviours, such as smoking less around others and forgoing cigarettes, and thinking about quitting. Almost half (n=8) of those in the post-study interview, predominantly women (n=6), reported that the use of plain packs had either increased avoidant behaviour or reduced consumption.
This pilot naturalistic study suggests that plain packaging could potentially help reduce tobacco consumption among some young adult smokers, and women in particular. Employing an innovative research methodology, the findings of this study are consistent with, and indeed support, past plain packaging research.
探索在现实环境中使用普通(无品牌)香烟包装对年轻成年吸烟者的影响。
采用自然主义研究方法,让吸烟者在现实环境中使用棕色“普通”包装 2 周,然后使用常规包装 2 周。参与者在苏格兰格拉斯哥招募。在这项自然主义研究中,140 名年龄在 18-35 岁的吸烟者中,有 48 名正确填写并返回了所有问卷。在为期 4 周的研究期间,参与者每周两次完成一份评估包装感知和感受、吸烟感受、健康警示的突出性和与吸烟相关行为的问卷。在研究结束后,18 名参与者中的一部分参加了一次访谈,采用半结构化主题指南评估使用普通包装的看法和经验。
数据中的趋势表明,与品牌包装相比,普通包装增加了对包装和吸烟的负面看法和感受。普通包装还增加了回避行为(隐藏包装、遮盖包装)、某些戒烟行为,如在他人身边吸烟减少和放弃吸烟,以及考虑戒烟。在参加研究结束后访谈的参与者中,有近一半(n=8),主要是女性(n=6),报告说使用普通包装要么增加了回避行为,要么减少了消费。
这项初步的自然主义研究表明,普通包装可能有助于减少一些年轻成年吸烟者,特别是女性的烟草消费。采用创新的研究方法,本研究的结果与过去的普通包装研究一致,实际上支持了过去的研究。