Fremault Antoine, Rodenstein Daniel
Clinique Saint-Joseph, Pneumology, Rue de la Duchere 6, Gilly, 6060, Belgium.
BMJ Case Rep. 2009;2009. doi: 10.1136/bcr.02.2009.1558. Epub 2009 Jul 14.
In the framework of an objective assessment of medical practices, it has become the rule to limit preoperative examinations, including thoracic imaging, in asymptomatic patients with a low surgical risk (that is, in "good health"). The insistence on the avoidance of "unnecessary" technical examinations in patients in seemingly good health may disregard common symptoms and lead to untoward consequences for the patients as we recently experienced in our respiratory department: two patients were admitted, one for a cavitary tuberculosis and the other one for a small cell carcinoma. These patients had uneventfully undergone in the recent weeks ear, nose and throat procedures and gynaecologic surgical procedures, respectively, without preoperative chest radiography as they were considered "asymptomatic" at the time of surgery. Retrospectively, ordinary symptoms (cough in the patient with cavitary tuberculosis and shortness of breath in the patient with lung carcinoma) were present but did not "ring a bell" during the preoperative assessment.
在对医疗实践进行客观评估的框架下,对于手术风险较低(即“健康状况良好”)的无症状患者,限制包括胸部成像在内的术前检查已成为常规做法。坚持避免对看似健康的患者进行“不必要”的技术检查,可能会忽视常见症状,并给患者带来不良后果,就像我们呼吸科最近所经历的那样:两名患者入院,一名患有空洞型肺结核,另一名患有小细胞癌。这些患者最近几周分别顺利接受了耳鼻喉科手术和妇科手术,术前均未进行胸部X光检查,因为他们在手术时被认为“无症状”。回顾来看,普通症状(空洞型肺结核患者的咳嗽和肺癌患者的呼吸急促)是存在的,但在术前评估时并未“敲响警钟”。