Nežádal Tomáš, Hovorka Jiří, Herman Erik, Němcová Iveta, Bajaček Michal, Stichová Eva
Department of Neurology, Epileptology and Neuropsychiatry, Na Františku Hospital, Prague, Czech Republic.
Neurol Res. 2011 Sep;33(7):694-700. doi: 10.1179/1743132811Y.0000000003.
The aim of our study was to assess the number of psychogenic non-epileptic seizures (PNES) in our patients with a refractory seizure disorder, to determine the 'typical' PNES semiology using video-EEG monitoring and describe other PNES parameters.
We evaluated prospectively 596 patients with pharmacoresistant seizures. All these patients underwent continuous video-EEG monitoring. In consenting patients, we used suggestive seizure provocation. We assessed seizure semiology, interictal EEG, brain MRI, psychiatric co-morbidities, personality profiles, and seizure outcome.
In the sample of 596 monitored patients, we detected 111 (19.3%) patients with PNES. Of the 111 patients with PNES, 86.5% had spontaneous and 76.5% had provoked seizures. The five most typical symptoms were: initially closed eyelids (67.6%), rapid tremor (47.7%), asynchronous limb movement (37.8%), preictal pseudosleep (33.3%), and side-to-side head movement (32.4%). Interictal EEG was rated as abnormal in 46.2% and with epileptiform abnormality in 9%. Brain MRI was abnormal in 32 (28.8%) patients. Personality disorders (46.8%), anxiety (39.6%), and depression (12.6%) were the most frequent additional psychiatric co-morbidities. PNES outcome after at least 2 years is reported; 22.5% patients was seizure-free; one-third had markedly reduced seizure frequency. We have not seen any negative impact of the provocative testing on the seizure outcome.
Video-EEG monitoring with suggestive seizure provocation supported by clinical psychiatric and psychological evaluation significantly contributes to the correct PNES diagnosis, while interictal EEG and brain MRI are frequently abnormal. Symptoms typical for PNES, as opposed to epileptic seizures, could be distinguished.
我们研究的目的是评估难治性癫痫患者中的心因性非癫痫性发作(PNES)数量,通过视频脑电图监测确定“典型”的PNES症状学,并描述其他PNES参数。
我们前瞻性地评估了596例药物难治性癫痫患者。所有这些患者均接受了连续视频脑电图监测。对于同意的患者,我们采用了诱导性癫痫激发试验。我们评估了癫痫发作症状学、发作间期脑电图、脑部磁共振成像、精神共病、人格特征和癫痫发作结果。
在596例接受监测的患者样本中,我们检测到111例(19.3%)患有PNES的患者。在这111例PNES患者中,86.5%有自发发作,76.5%有诱发发作。五个最典型的症状是:最初眼睑闭合(67.6%)、快速震颤(47.7%)、肢体运动不同步(37.8%)、发作前假睡眠(33.3%)和头部左右移动(32.4%)。发作间期脑电图46.2%被评为异常,9%有癫痫样异常。脑部磁共振成像在32例(28.8%)患者中异常。人格障碍(46.8%)、焦虑(39.6%)和抑郁(12.6%)是最常见的其他精神共病。报告了至少2年后的PNES结果;22.5%的患者无癫痫发作;三分之一的患者癫痫发作频率明显降低。我们未发现激发试验对癫痫发作结果有任何负面影响。
临床精神和心理评估支持下的视频脑电图监测及诱导性癫痫激发试验对正确诊断PNES有显著帮助,而发作间期脑电图和脑部磁共振成像常为异常。与癫痫发作不同,PNES的典型症状可以区分。