[Real angulation degree in fifth metacarpal neck fracture].

OBJECTIVES

This study investigated whether the confusion about the acceptable angulation value in fifth metacarpal neck fractures results from the hand radiographs taken at non-standard oblique position.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

In this experimental study two Kirshner wires representing the intramedullary axis of the two fracture fragments were placed on a platform prearranged with an angle of 50 degrees between them. The radiographs of the wires were taken on the platform (horizontal) at angles of 0, 30, 45 and 60 degrees. The radiographs were taken without changing the cassette location and the position of the radiography device.

RESULTS

The known volar angulation (50 degrees) was measured on the radiographs as 50, 36, 30 and 23 degrees, respectively.

CONCLUSION

The main debate about the fifth metacarpal neck fracture is over the acceptable distal fragment volar angulation degree. This degree of angulation is between 30 and 70 degrees in the studies. The presence of such different and inaccurate results in the literature results from the use of non-standard oblique hand radiographs. Standardized radiographs are required in fifth metacarpal neck fractures.