Neurology Department, Vall d'Hebron Hospital, Universitat Autonoma de Barcelona, Barcelona, Spain.
Epilepsy Res. 2011 Nov;97(1-2):30-6. doi: 10.1016/j.eplepsyres.2011.06.013. Epub 2011 Jul 23.
This study aims to demonstrate the reliability of the diagnosis of epilepsy after a new onset seizure, supported by a detailed anamnesis and the complementary tests accessible at the emergency room (ER), such as CT-scan and video-EEG. It was a prospective study including 131 adult patients (55% males, medium age 52.42 (±21.5)[16-98] years-old, follow-up 25.22 (±13.69)[12-31] months). In half of cases we could not identify any predisposing factor. Within the first 72 h, patients were included into an epileptic syndrome according to the ILAE 1989 classification, if possible. Thereafter, they were followed-up in the outpatient clinic of the Epilepsy Unit, where seizure recurrence was recorded and further diagnostic examinations were performed. 94.1% of patients initially diagnosed of epilepsy were confirmed as epileptics, and up to 57% of patients could be classified into a particular syndrome from the ER. Conversely, 44.6% of patients with the initial diagnosis of isolated seizure and one third of patients with non-epileptic seizures developed recurrence, switching their initial diagnosis to epilepsy. Both CT-scan and early EEG demonstrated its usefulness evaluating the risk of recurrence after a new onset seizure (Positive predictive value 78% and 88%, respectively). Epileptiform activity was a predictor of seizure recurrence (p<0.05), independently to the moment where the EEG was performed. According to our results, it is realistic to perform the diagnosis of epilepsy after a new onset seizure, although many patients still need further specific examinations, or seizure recurrence, to be diagnosed.
本研究旨在通过详细的病史和急诊室(ER)可获得的补充检查(如 CT 扫描和视频脑电图),证明新发性癫痫发作后癫痫诊断的可靠性。这是一项前瞻性研究,共纳入 131 例成年患者(55%为男性,平均年龄为 52.42(±21.5)[16-98]岁,随访时间为 25.22(±13.69)[12-31]个月)。在一半的病例中,我们无法确定任何诱发因素。在最初的 72 小时内,如果可能,根据 ILAE 1989 分类将患者纳入癫痫综合征。此后,他们在癫痫科的门诊接受随访,记录癫痫发作复发情况,并进行进一步的诊断检查。最初诊断为癫痫的患者中,94.1%得到了确认,多达 57%的患者可以在 ER 中分类为特定的综合征。相反,44.6%的初始诊断为孤立性发作的患者和三分之一的非癫痫性发作患者出现复发,从而将其初始诊断更改为癫痫。CT 扫描和早期脑电图均证明其在评估新发癫痫发作后复发风险方面有用(阳性预测值分别为 78%和 88%)。癫痫样活动是癫痫复发的预测因素(p<0.05),与 EEG 进行的时间无关。根据我们的结果,虽然许多患者仍需要进一步的特定检查或癫痫发作复发才能得到诊断,但在新发性癫痫发作后进行癫痫诊断是可行的。