Van Loveren C
Department of Cariology & Endodontology, Academic Center for Dentistry Amsterdam (ACTA), The Netherlands.
J Dent Res. 1990 Feb;69 Spec No:676-81; discussion 682-3. doi: 10.1177/00220345900690S131.
Despite a considerable amount of literature on the effects of fluoride in dental plaque, several urgent questions remain unanswered, such as: Does the inhibiting effect of fluoride on dental plaque metabolism contribute to caries prevention? Does adaptation of plaque to fluoride affect its cariogenicity? Single applications of fluoride directly to dental plaque reduced acid production. Also, fluoride dissolving from topically treated enamel reduced the acid production in covering layers of oral bacteria in vitro. The effects of both treatments were only of short duration and may not be relevant to caries prevention in vivo. In contrast, daily applications of fluoride resulted in a reduction of the acidogenicity of dental plaque even 8-12 h after the treatment. Such a reduction is likely to contribute to caries prevention. But it has to be realized that when plaque reaches saturation with respect to fluoridated calcium (phosphate) precipitates, enamel becomes insoluble and any antimicrobial effect becomes irrelevant. Still lacking are data on the antimicrobial effects of fluoride regimens normally used in home care, in weekly rinsing programs in schools, or treatments applied professionally every six months. Adaptation of Streptococcus mutans to fluoride has been suggested to reduce the cariogenic potential of the cells. In vitro-induced fluoride-resistant strains were less cariogenic in rats, and the velocity of acid production in vitro was reduced at constant pH greater than 5.5. Despite the ability of oral bacteria to adapt to fluoride, evidence of adaptation in dental plaque of normal subjects resulting in a reduced cariogenic potential has not yet been demonstrated.
尽管有大量关于氟化物对牙菌斑影响的文献,但仍有几个紧迫问题未得到解答,例如:氟化物对牙菌斑代谢的抑制作用是否有助于预防龋齿?牙菌斑对氟化物的适应性是否会影响其致龋性?直接将氟化物单次应用于牙菌斑可减少酸的产生。此外,从局部处理过的牙釉质中溶解的氟化物在体外可减少口腔细菌覆盖层中的酸产生。这两种处理的效果都只是短期的,可能与体内龋齿预防无关。相比之下,每日应用氟化物即使在治疗后8 - 12小时也能降低牙菌斑的产酸性。这种降低可能有助于预防龋齿。但必须认识到,当牙菌斑相对于氟化钙(磷酸盐)沉淀物达到饱和时,牙釉质变得不溶,任何抗菌作用都变得无关紧要。目前仍缺乏关于家庭护理中常用的氟化物方案、学校每周冲洗方案或每六个月专业应用的治疗方法的抗菌效果的数据。有人提出变形链球菌对氟化物的适应性可降低细胞的致龋潜力。体外诱导的耐氟菌株在大鼠中致龋性较低,并且在恒定pH大于5.5时体外产酸速度降低。尽管口腔细菌有能力适应氟化物,但尚未证明正常受试者牙菌斑中的适应性会导致致龋潜力降低。