Angle Orthod. 2012 Jan;82(1):122-30. doi: 10.2319/020911-95.1. Epub 2011 Jul 27.
To validate the use of three-dimensional (3-D) surface rendering (SR) images to quantify the height of alveolar dehiscences.
Twenty-four dehiscences were created on 9 incisors, 9 canines, and 6 premolars on 4 cadaver skulls. i-CAT cone beam computed tomography scans (CBCTs) were taken of each skull at .2 mm voxel size. Each dehiscence was quantified by 21 orthodontic residents using 3-D SR. The principal investigator (PI) also quantified each dehiscence using the 2-D multiplanar (MP) image and the 3-D SR image.
Results of this study showed an average method error of the residents as a group to be 0.57 mm with an intraclass correlation (ICC) of 0.77%. Residents' method error ranged from 0.45 mm to 1.32 mm, and the ICC ranged from 0.201% to 0.857%. Systematic error was low at -0.01 mm for the direct measurement compared with the residents' average 3-D SR at 1365 density value (DV) measurement. The 3-D SR at 1365 DV images were compared with the MP and 3-D SR images at 1200 DV, and no significant differences in measurements and low systematic error were noted. The method error of the PI was 0.45 mm, 0.45 mm, and 0.41 mm for 3-D SR at 1365 DV, 3-D SR at 1200 DV, and 2-D MP, respectively.
3-D SR and 2D MRP can be used to measure dehiscences of the periodontium with similar levels of accuracy.
验证三维(3-D)表面渲染(SR)图像在量化牙槽裂高度方面的应用。
在 4 个尸头的 9 颗切牙、9 颗尖牙和 6 颗前磨牙上共制作 24 个牙槽裂。使用 i-CAT 锥形束 CT(CBCT)以.2 毫米体素大小对每个颅骨进行扫描。21 名正畸住院医师使用 3-D SR 对每个牙槽裂进行定量。主要研究者(PI)还使用 2-D 多平面(MP)图像和 3-D SR 图像对每个牙槽裂进行定量。
本研究结果显示,作为一个整体,住院医师的平均方法误差为 0.57 毫米,组内相关系数(ICC)为 0.77%。住院医师的方法误差范围为 0.45 毫米至 1.32 毫米,ICC 范围为 0.201%至 0.857%。与居民平均 1365 密度值(DV)测量的 3-D SR 相比,直接测量的系统误差较低,为-0.01 毫米。比较 1365 DV 的 3-D SR 图像与 1200 DV 的 MP 和 3-D SR 图像,测量值无显著差异,且系统误差较低。PI 的 3-D SR 在 1365 DV、1200 DV 和 2-D MP 中的方法误差分别为 0.45 毫米、0.45 毫米和 0.41 毫米。
3-D SR 和 2-D MRP 可用于测量牙周的牙槽裂,其准确度相似。