Salazar-Fernandez Clara Isabel, Herce Javier, Garcia-Palma Alfonso, Delgado Jose, Martín Jose Felix, Soto Teresa
Virgen Macarena Hospital Area, Seville, Spain.
J Oral Maxillofac Surg. 2012 Feb;70(2):295-301. doi: 10.1016/j.joms.2011.03.053. Epub 2011 Jul 30.
To evaluate the effectiveness of a store-and-forward telemedicine system (SFTMS) as an optimal method for the selection, diagnosis and treatment of patients with TMJ disorders (TMJD) referred from primary care sites to the Maxillofacial Surgery Unit (hospital-based).
A multicenter, analytical, quasi-experimental, non-randomized clinical study of a SFTMS aimed towards the management of patients with TMJD was conducted at the Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery Unit of the Virgen Macarena University Hospital (Seville, Spain) and 10 primary care areas of the North area of Seville located between 15 and 180 km from the hospital. The study was carried out between January 2008 and February 2010 including a non-random sample consisting of all patients with TMJD treated at primary care sites during the study period. We describe the development and effectiveness of this method based on the rates of diagnosis of myofascial syndrome and/or internal deragement Wilkes Stages I-II-III, internal deragement Wilkes Stages IV-V, other arthropathies, resolved teleconsultations, second teleconsultations, referrals to hospital, mean treatment delay, lost hours working/patient and complaints. The same variables were also described for the TMJD conventional consultation system at hospital (standard system). Descriptive statistics (frequency tables, means and medians, and dispersion measures), T-Student test was used to compare the differences in the average quantitative variables (time) and Chi2 test was used to compare the differences in the average qualitative variables.
Over a 24-month period, 710 patients with TMJD were assisted at hospital by conventional consultation from 1-1-2008 to 2-25-2010, of which 587 (82.7%) were women and 123 (17.3%) were men with a mean age of 41.08 years. The mean time elapsed until treatment onset was 78.6 days, with a mean cost of 32 lost working hours per patient. In this period, 342 patients with TMJD were assisted by teleconsultation, of which 276 (80.7%) were women and 66 (19.2%) were men with a mean age of 38.3 years. Only 35 (10%) patients presented some other TMJ pathology that required maxillofacial surgery. The remaining 307 (89.7%) received non-surgical treatment in the primary care center (high resolutive consultations) in a mean time of 2.3 days (p<0.05), and a mean cost of 16 lost working hours/patient (p<0.05).
Telemedicine allows a correct diagnosis and an adequate treatment for the majority of TMJD from primary care sites and shortens the delay in treatment onset, preventing displacement and unnecessary costs for these patients.
评估存储转发远程医疗系统(SFTMS)作为一种从基层医疗点转诊至颌面外科病房(医院内)的颞下颌关节紊乱病(TMJD)患者的选择、诊断及治疗的最佳方法的有效性。
在西班牙塞维利亚的马卡雷纳圣母大学医院口腔颌面外科病房及塞维利亚北部地区距离医院15至180公里的10个基层医疗区域,开展了一项针对TMJD患者管理的SFTMS多中心、分析性、准实验性、非随机临床研究。该研究于2008年1月至2010年2月进行,纳入研究期间在基层医疗点接受治疗的所有TMJD患者组成的非随机样本。我们基于肌筋膜综合征和/或Wilkes I-II-III期关节内紊乱、Wilkes IV-V期关节内紊乱、其他关节病的诊断率、远程会诊解决情况、二次远程会诊、转诊至医院情况、平均治疗延迟、每位患者损失的工作时长及投诉情况,描述该方法的开展及有效性。还针对医院的TMJD传统会诊系统(标准系统)描述了相同变量。采用描述性统计(频率表、均值和中位数以及离散度指标),T检验用于比较平均定量变量(时间)的差异,卡方检验用于比较平均定性变量的差异。
在24个月期间,2008年1月1日至2010年2月25日期间,710例TMJD患者在医院接受了传统会诊,其中587例(82.7%)为女性,123例(17.3%)为男性,平均年龄41.08岁。治疗开始前的平均时间为78.6天,每位患者平均损失32个工作日。在此期间,342例TMJD患者接受了远程会诊,其中276例(80.7%)为女性,66例(19.2%)为男性,平均年龄38.3岁。仅35例(10%)患者存在其他需要颌面外科手术的颞下颌关节病变。其余307例(89.7%)在基层医疗中心接受了非手术治疗(高分辨率会诊),平均时间为2.3天(p<0.05),每位患者平均损失16个工作日(p<0.05)。
远程医疗能够对大多数来自基层医疗点的TMJD患者进行正确诊断和适当治疗,缩短治疗开始的延迟,避免这些患者的奔波及不必要的费用。