Faculdade São Leopoldo Mandic, School of Dentistry, Campinas, Brazil.
Dentomaxillofac Radiol. 2011 Sep;40(6):369-78. doi: 10.1259/dmfr/88722046.
The aim of this study was to evaluate accuracy of linear measurements assessed from axial tomograms and the influence of the use of different protocols in two cone beam CT (CBCT) units.
A cylinder object consisting of Nylon® (Day Brazil, Sao Paulo, Brazil) with radiopaque markers was radiographically examined applying different protocols from NewTom 3G(TM) (Quantitative Radiology s.r.l, Verona, Veneto, Italy) and i-CAT(TM) (Imaging Sciences International, Hatfield, PA) units. Horizontal (A-B) and vertical (C-D) distances were assessed from axial tomograms and measured using a digital calliper that provided the gold standard for actual values.
There were differences when considering acquisition protocols to each CBCT unit. Concerning all analysed protocols from i-CAT(TM) and Newtom 3G(TM), both A-B and C-D distances presented underestimated values. Measurements of the axial images obtained from NewTom 3G(TM) (6 inch 0.16 mm and 9 inch 0.25 mm) were similar to the ones obtained from i-CAT(TM) (13 cm 20 s 0.3 mm, 13 cm 20 s 0.4 mm and 13 cm 40 s 0.25 mm).
The use of different protocols from CBCT machines influences linear measurements assessed from axial images. Linear distances were underestimated in both equipments. Our findings suggest that the best protocol for the i-CAT(TM) is 13 cm 20 s 0.3 mm and for the NewTom 3G(TM), the use of 6 inch or 9 inch is recommended.
本研究旨在评估从轴向断层图像得出的线性测量的准确性,以及在两个锥形束 CT(CBCT)设备中使用不同方案的影响。
使用 NewTom 3G(TM)(定量放射学有限公司,维罗纳,威尼托,意大利)和 i-CAT(TM)(成像科学国际公司,哈特菲尔德,宾夕法尼亚州)的不同方案对由 Nylon®(Day Brazil,圣保罗,巴西)制成的带有放射性标记的圆柱体物体进行放射照相检查。从轴向断层图像评估水平(A-B)和垂直(C-D)距离,并使用数字卡尺进行测量,该卡尺为实际值提供了金标准。
考虑到每个 CBCT 设备的采集方案,存在差异。对于 i-CAT(TM)和 Newtom 3G(TM)的所有分析方案,A-B 和 C-D 距离均呈现出低估值。从 NewTom 3G(TM)(6 英寸 0.16 毫米和 9 英寸 0.25 毫米)获得的轴向图像的测量值与从 i-CAT(TM)获得的测量值相似(13 厘米 20 秒 0.3 毫米,13 厘米 20 秒 0.4 毫米和 13 厘米 40 秒 0.25 毫米)。
CBCT 机器的不同方案的使用会影响从轴向图像评估得出的线性测量。两种设备的线性距离均被低估。我们的研究结果表明,i-CAT(TM)的最佳方案为 13 厘米 20 秒 0.3 毫米,而对于 NewTom 3G(TM),建议使用 6 英寸或 9 英寸。