Nelson Craig, Chand Pushkar, Sortais Julie, Oloimooja Joseph, Rembert Gina
South Bay MedicalCenter in Harbor City, CA, USA.
Perm J. 2011 Spring;15(2):48-51. doi: 10.7812/TPP/10-142.
Many patients and their families have difficulty making decisions when confronted with complex medical problems. Often their expectations and hopes are beyond what medical science can deliver, and at times their desires seem to conflict with their treatment plans. Additionally, costly tests and treatments with little or no benefit are often explored. Inpatient palliative care consultation services for end-of-life-care planning can help patients navigate this complexity, arrive at a care plan consistent with their personal values, and be good stewards of precious medical resources.
We conducted a study to assess the effect that one function of our organization's Inpatient Palliative Care Service-consultation regarding end-of-life-care planning-has on readmission rates. We believed that our study would show that interdisciplinary end-of-life-care planning improves resource use by reducing the probability and rate of hospital readmission.
We retrospectively reviewed electronic records for Kaiser Permanente HealthConnect at Kaiser Permanente South Bay Medical Center in Harbor City, CA, for 200 consecutive patients referred to our Inpatient Palliative Care Service between November 2006 and February 2010, comparing hospital readmissions between two groups of patients. Members of both groups (100 patients in each) all had an Inpatient Palliative Care consult ordered for end-of-life-care planning; members of group A were seen solely by an inpatient palliative care registered nurse (RN), whereas members of group B were seen by an interdisciplinary team consisting of a physician, a bioethicist, a social worker, an RN, and a hospital chaplain.
We found that with the post-team consultation, readmissions to the hospital per patient per six months after consultation decreased from 1.15 to 0.7 admissions per patient.
许多患者及其家属在面对复杂的医疗问题时难以做出决策。他们的期望和希望往往超出了医学所能提供的范围,有时他们的愿望似乎与治疗计划相冲突。此外,人们常常会探索那些益处甚微或毫无益处却成本高昂的检查和治疗方法。针对临终关怀规划的住院姑息治疗咨询服务能够帮助患者应对这种复杂性,制定出符合其个人价值观的护理计划,并成为珍贵医疗资源的明智管理者。
我们开展了一项研究,以评估本机构住院姑息治疗服务的一项功能——关于临终关怀规划的咨询——对再入院率的影响。我们认为我们的研究将表明,跨学科的临终关怀规划通过降低医院再入院的可能性和比率来改善资源利用。
我们回顾性地查阅了加利福尼亚州港市凯撒南湾医疗中心凯撒永久医疗健康连接系统的电子记录,这些记录来自2006年11月至2010年2月期间连续转诊至我们住院姑息治疗服务的200名患者,比较两组患者的医院再入院情况。两组(每组100名患者)的成员都因临终关怀规划而接受了住院姑息治疗咨询;A组成员仅由一名住院姑息治疗注册护士诊治,而B组成员由一个跨学科团队诊治,该团队包括一名医生、一名生物伦理学家、一名社会工作者、一名注册护士和一名医院牧师。
我们发现,经过团队咨询后,每位患者在咨询后每六个月的医院再入院率从1.15次降至0.7次。