den Held O M, Hegge I R H J, van Schaik D J F, van Balkom A J L M
PPC Amsterdam, Postbus 41.901, 1009 CE Amsterdam.
Tijdschr Psychiatr. 2011;53(8):519-30.
The attitudes of medical students to psychiatry are important for the future care of patients with psychiatric (co)morbidity. Up till now the attitude of medical students to psychiatry has not been investigated in the Netherlands and the Dutch-speaking part of Belgium.
To measure the attitude of third year medical students towards psychiatry by means of the ATP-30. This is a validated instrument, used internationally. To determine the extent to which medical students' attitudes were influenced by the psychiatry curriculum and by some sociodemographic determinants and which aspects of a career – according to earlier Dutch research – made students decide to opt for a particular specialism.
Our research was of the prospective cohort type; without controls. The design was a pre- and post design.
Attitudes to psychiatry were generally positive (n = 262, ATP score: 106.1, sd 10.9, ATP score ≤ 90 was regarded as negative) and improved after students received instruction in psychiatry. Men were less positive than women. Students who previously had positive experiences with the psychiatric services had higher scores. Foreign students, mainly from non-Western countries, had lower scores. After these foreign students had completed their studies in the Netherlands, there was no longer any significant difference between the scores of the two groups.
Attitudes to psychiatry are positive within our cohort. Tuition has a positive effect on students' attitudes. The less positive score of the foreign students at the start of their course is probably due to the fact that they were not familiar with psychiatry and psychiatric services.
医学生对精神病学的态度对于未来患有精神疾病(合并症)患者的护理至关重要。到目前为止,荷兰和比利时荷语区尚未对医学生对精神病学的态度进行过调查。
通过ATP - 30量表测量三年级医学生对精神病学的态度。这是一种经过验证的工具,在国际上使用。根据荷兰早期的研究,确定医学生的态度在多大程度上受到精神病学课程、一些社会人口统计学决定因素的影响,以及职业的哪些方面会使学生决定选择某一特定专业。
我们的研究属于前瞻性队列研究类型;无对照组。设计为前后对照设计。
对精神病学的态度总体上是积极的(n = 262,ATP得分:106.1,标准差10.9,ATP得分≤90被视为消极),并且在学生接受精神病学教学后有所改善。男性的态度不如女性积极。以前在精神科服务中有过积极体验的学生得分更高。主要来自非西方国家的外国学生得分较低。这些外国学生在荷兰完成学业后,两组的得分不再有显著差异。
我们队列中的学生对精神病学的态度是积极的。教学对学生的态度有积极影响。外国学生在课程开始时得分较低可能是因为他们不熟悉精神病学和精神科服务。