Quality Management Department, King Saud Chest Specialty Hospital, Saudi Arabia.
J Patient Saf. 2011 Sep;7(3):144-7. doi: 10.1097/PTS.0b013e31822c5a82.
: Accurate medical error reporting is crucial for reducing the occurrence of such errors and their adverse consequences. This study aims to investigate the views of physicians about medical error reporting in a tertiary care hospital in Saudi Arabia.
: This is a cross-sectional self-administrated survey study. All physicians in the hospital were invited to complete an anonymous survey questionnaire addressing demographic details, as well as attitudes, practice, and views on medical error reporting.
: One hundred seven physicians completed the questionnaires (66.5% response rate). Mean (SD) age was 39.8 (9.0) years. One-fifth of the respondents worked in the emergency department, and half had a workload of 40 to 59 h/wk. The reason given by 41.1% for not reporting a medical error by a colleague was that "it is not their responsibility." However, the gravity of the outcome of a medical error by a colleague to the patient was thought to be an important incentive for reporting. Of the physicians, 43% agreed that they would conceal the occurrence of a medical error they incurred to "avoid punishment." Nevertheless, most of the respondents held the view that there exists an ethical underpinning for reporting medical errors and that reporting of medical errors serve a valuable purpose.
: The physicians in our study are likely to disclose errors made by a colleague only if the error resulted in a severe damage to the patient, and as such, medical errors go underreported for a variety of reasons. It was felt that assurance of confidentiality and protection from backlash would promote medical error disclosure.
准确报告医疗差错对于减少此类差错及其不良后果至关重要。本研究旨在调查沙特阿拉伯一家三级保健医院的医生对医疗差错报告的看法。
这是一项横断面自我管理的调查研究。邀请医院的所有医生填写一份匿名调查问卷,内容涉及人口统计学细节,以及对医疗差错报告的态度、实践和看法。
107 名医生完成了问卷(66.5%的应答率)。平均(SD)年龄为 39.8(9.0)岁。五分之一的受访者在急诊科工作,一半的人每周工作 40 到 59 小时。41.1%的人不报告同事的医疗差错的原因是“这不是他们的责任”。然而,同事的医疗差错对患者的后果严重程度被认为是报告的重要激励因素。43%的医生同意他们会隐瞒自己犯下的医疗差错,以“避免惩罚”。然而,大多数受访者认为报告医疗差错有伦理依据,而且报告医疗差错有其价值。
在我们的研究中,医生只有在同事的错误严重损害了患者的情况下才可能披露该错误,因此,由于各种原因,医疗差错被大量隐瞒。人们认为,保证保密性和免受反弹的保护将促进医疗差错的披露。