Chakraborty R, Bose K, Koziel S
Department of Anthropology, Dinabandhu Mahavidyalaya, Bongaon, West Bengal, India.
Rural Remote Health. 2011;11(3):1754. Epub 2011 Aug 31.
Body mass index (BMI) is widely accepted as one of the best indicators of nutritional status in adults. Mid-upper arm circumference (MUAC) is another anthropometric measure that has also been used to evaluate adult nutritional status. The objective of this study was to evaluate the use of MUAC as a simpler and reliable alternative to BMI. A suitable cut-off value was also proposed for identification of chronic energy deficiency (CED) in relation to self-reported illness among the adult Oraon males of Jharkhand state in India.
The study was based on a cross-sectional survey involving 205 rural adult men belonging to the Oraon tribal group of Jharkand State in India. Height and weight were measured for each participant. The BMI was calculated as kg/m2. The internationally accepted cut-off points of BMI and MUAC were utilised to determine nutritional status. An episode of illness was recorded for each subject if any working day was lost. Receiver operating characteristic curve analyses were undertaken to discover the most suitable values of MUAC both for CED and illness.
The MUAC values of 243 and 239 mm were identified as the best cut offs to identify CED (BMI<18.5) and illness, respectively. There were marked increases in both CED and illness prevalence rates at a MUAC level lower than 240 mm. Therefore, a MUAC value of close to 240 mm seemed appropriate as a simple and efficient cut-off point for the determination of undernutrition and higher rates of illness and loss of working days in adult Oraon males.
Because MUAC is a much simpler measure than BMI, the use of MUAC 240 mm as a cut-off point is predicted to have considerable public health implications, especially with respect to primary health care related to CED and morbidity.
体重指数(BMI)被广泛认为是评估成年人营养状况的最佳指标之一。上臂中部周长(MUAC)是另一种人体测量指标,也已用于评估成年人的营养状况。本研究的目的是评估将MUAC作为一种比BMI更简单且可靠的替代指标的适用性。还针对印度贾坎德邦成年奥拉昂男性中与自我报告疾病相关的慢性能量缺乏(CED)的识别提出了一个合适的临界值。
该研究基于一项横断面调查,涉及印度贾坎德邦奥拉昂部落群体的205名农村成年男性。测量了每位参与者的身高和体重。BMI的计算单位为kg/m²。采用国际公认的BMI和MUAC临界值来确定营养状况。如果任何工作日有损失,则记录每个受试者的疾病发作情况。进行了受试者工作特征曲线分析,以找出用于CED和疾病的最合适的MUAC值。
分别确定243毫米和239毫米的MUAC值为识别CED(BMI<18.5)和疾病的最佳临界值。在MUAC水平低于240毫米时,CED和疾病患病率均显著增加。因此,接近240毫米的MUAC值似乎适合作为确定成年奥拉昂男性营养不良以及较高疾病率和工作日损失率的简单有效临界值。
由于MUAC是一种比BMI简单得多的测量方法,预计将MUAC 240毫米作为临界值会对公共卫生产生重大影响,特别是在与CED和发病率相关的初级卫生保健方面。