Chilibeck Philip D, Cornish Stephen M, Schulte Al, Jantz Nathan, Magnus Charlene R A, Schwanbeck Shane, Juurlink Bernhard H J
J Can Chiropr Assoc. 2011 Sep;55(3):183-92.
We hypothesized that spinal manipulation (SM) would reduce strength imbalances between legs. Using an un-blinded randomized design, 28 males and 21 females (54 ± 19y) with at least a 15% difference in isometric strength between legs for hip flexion, extension, abduction, or knee flexion were randomized to treatment or placebo (mock spinal manipulation). Strength of the stronger and weaker legs for hip flexion, extension, abduction, and/or knee flexion was assessed before and after the intervention. SM reduced the relative strength difference between legs for knee flexion (mean ± SD 57 ± 53 to 5 ± 14%) and hip flexion (24 ± 12 to 11 ± 15%) compared to placebo (34 ± 29 to 24 ± 36%, and 20 ± 18 to 22 ± 26%, respectively) (p = 0.05). SM also improved strength in the weak leg for hip abduction (104 ± 43 to 116 ± 43 Nm) compared to placebo (84 ± 24 to 85 ± 31 Nm) (p = 0.03). This study suggests that spinal manipulation may reduce imbalances in strength between legs for knee and hip flexion.
我们假设脊柱推拿(SM)可以减少双腿之间的力量失衡。采用非盲随机设计,将28名男性和21名女性(54±19岁)随机分为治疗组或安慰剂组(模拟脊柱推拿),这些受试者双腿在髋关节屈伸、外展或膝关节屈伸等长力量上至少有15%的差异。在干预前后评估双腿在髋关节屈伸、外展和/或膝关节屈伸时较强和较弱一侧的力量。与安慰剂组相比(分别为34±29至24±36%和20±18至22±26%),脊柱推拿降低了膝关节屈伸(平均值±标准差从57±53降至5±14%)和髋关节屈伸(从24±12降至11±15%)时双腿之间的相对力量差异(p = 0.05)。与安慰剂组相比(84±24至85±31牛米),脊柱推拿还提高了髋关节外展时较弱一侧的力量(从104±43至116±43牛米)(p = 0.03)。这项研究表明,脊柱推拿可能会减少膝关节和髋关节屈伸时双腿之间的力量失衡。