Schembre Susan M, Nigg Claudio R, Albright Cheryl L
University of Hawai'i Cancer Center, Prevention and Control Program, Honolulu, HI 96813, USA.
Hawaii Med J. 2011 Jul;70(7 Suppl 1):32-6.
In accordance with the sociocultural model, race/ethnicity is considered a major influence on factors associated with body image and body dissatisfaction, and eating disorders are often characterized as problems that are primarily limited to young White women from Western cultures. The purpose of this study was to determine whether there are differences that exist by race in desired body weight; the importance placed on those ideals; and dieting strategies among White, Asian American, Native Hawaiian/Pacific Islanders, and other mixed-race young women in Hawai'i. A total of 144 female college students 18-20 years of age were surveyed about body weight as well as eating and exercise habits. Results demonstrated that all the young women wanted to lose weight. However, there were no differences in desired body weight or desired weight change by race after controlling for body mass index suggesting that current weight rather than race/ethnicity is the predominant influence on weight-related concerns. Young White women placed the greatest level of importance on achieving a lower body weight, which corresponded with a greater likelihood to be attempting weight loss (dieting) and greater endorsement of behaviors consistent with weight loss compared to their counterparts. Findings imply that, for young women, race/ethnicity may not have as significant an impact on factors associated with body weight ideals as previously believed. Rather, differences in the value placed on achieving a desired body weight, as it relates to disordered eating, should be further explored among race/ethnic groups.
根据社会文化模型,种族/族裔被认为是对与身体形象和身体不满相关因素的主要影响因素,饮食失调通常被描述为主要局限于西方文化中的年轻白人女性的问题。本研究的目的是确定在夏威夷的白人、亚裔美国人、夏威夷原住民/太平洋岛民以及其他混血年轻女性中,在理想体重、对这些理想的重视程度以及节食策略方面是否存在种族差异。对144名年龄在18至20岁之间的女大学生进行了关于体重以及饮食和运动习惯的调查。结果表明,所有年轻女性都想减肥。然而,在控制体重指数后,理想体重或理想体重变化在种族方面没有差异,这表明当前体重而非种族/族裔是与体重相关问题的主要影响因素。与其他同龄人相比,年轻白人女性对达到更低体重最为重视,这与更有可能尝试减肥(节食)以及更支持与减肥一致的行为相对应。研究结果表明,对于年轻女性来说,种族/族裔对与理想体重相关因素的影响可能并不像以前认为的那么显著。相反,在不同种族/族裔群体中,应进一步探讨在实现理想体重方面所赋予的价值差异与饮食失调的关系。