HSS J. 2010 Sep;6(2):164-70. doi: 10.1007/s11420-009-9152-5. Epub 2010 Feb 2.
Much current research is focused on biologic enhancement of the tendon repair process. To evaluate the different methods, which include a variety of gene therapy and tissue engineering techniques, histological and biomechanical testing is often employed. Both modalities offer information on the progress and quality of repair; however, they have been historically considered as two separate entities. Histological evaluation is a less costly undertaking; however, there is no validated scoring scale to compare the results of different studies or even the results within a given study. Biomechanical testing can provide validated outcome measures; however, it is associated with increased cost and is more labor intensive. We hypothesized that a properly developed, objective histological scoring system would provide a validated outcome measure to compare histological results and correlate with biomechanics. In an Achilles tendon model, we have developed a histological scoring scale to assess tendon repair. The system grades collagen orientation, angiogenesis, and cartilage induction. In this study, histology scores were plotted against biomechanical testing results of healing tendons which indicated that a strong linear correlation exists between the histological properties of repaired tendons and their biomechanical characteristics. Concordantly, this study provides a pragmatic and financially feasible means of evaluating repair while accounting for both the histology and biomechanical properties observed in surgically repaired, healing tendon.
目前的许多研究都集中在生物增强肌腱修复过程上。为了评估不同的方法,包括各种基因治疗和组织工程技术,经常进行组织学和生物力学测试。这两种方法都提供了关于修复进展和质量的信息;然而,它们在历史上被认为是两个独立的实体。组织学评估的费用较低;然而,没有经过验证的评分标准来比较不同研究的结果,甚至是同一研究内的结果。生物力学测试可以提供经过验证的结果衡量标准;然而,它与增加的成本和更密集的劳动力相关。我们假设一个经过适当开发的、客观的组织学评分系统将提供一个经过验证的结果衡量标准,以比较组织学结果并与生物力学相关联。在跟腱模型中,我们已经开发了一种组织学评分系统来评估肌腱修复。该系统对胶原取向、血管生成和软骨诱导进行分级。在这项研究中,组织学评分与愈合肌腱的生物力学测试结果相关联,这表明修复后的肌腱的组织学特性与其生物力学特性之间存在很强的线性相关性。一致地,这项研究提供了一种实用且经济可行的方法来评估修复,同时考虑到手术修复后愈合肌腱的组织学和生物力学特性。