Colón-Otero Gerardo, King Sherry, Smith Vandelyn, Bieber Carolyn, Crook Julia, Solberg Lawrence A, Shannon Robert, Perez Edith A
Mayo Clinic Cancer Center, Cancer Health Disparities Program, Jacksonville, Florida.
Clin Med Oncol. 2008;2:547-50. doi: 10.4137/cmo.s988. Epub 2008 Nov 3.
A prospective analysis of women with terminal breast cancer admitted to CHNE from November 2006-August 2007 evaluated anecdotal observations that African American (AA) women are likelier than Caucasian women to evidence loco-regional recurrences (LRR). Women with terminal breast cancer who were admitted to CHNE, a not-for-profit hospice serving over 90% of Northeast Florida hospice patients, were eligible for participation. 134 terminal breast cancer patients were assessed by hospice nurses for LRR presence via chest wall examination. 80% of them (107) were Caucasian, 17% (23) were AA and 3% (4) were of other ethnicities. Evidence of LRR were noted in 13% of the women (17/134). The proportion of patients with LRR was higher in AA women than Caucasian women (26% vs. 10%, 6/23 vs. 11/107, respectively), although this difference was not statistically significant (p = 0.08). The majority of Caucasian women with LRR consented to a medical record review, but a minority of AA women consented (8/11 vs. 2/6, respectively, p = 0.16).
Evaluating disparities in breast cancer care outcomes is possible by reviewing data from patients served by hospice programs that aid a majority of patients within a community. This pilot data suggests that AA women with breast cancer have a higher incidence of loco-regional failure as a component of their terminal breast cancer disease than Caucasian women. A smaller proportion of AA patients and families agreed to participate in a medical record review study than Caucasians. Larger studies are necessary to confirm these findings, to elucidate factors contributing to disparities and to develop potential solutions.
对2006年11月至2007年8月入住CHNE的晚期乳腺癌女性进行前瞻性分析,评估了一些传闻观察结果,即非裔美国(AA)女性比白人女性更有可能出现局部区域复发(LRR)。入住CHNE的晚期乳腺癌女性符合参与条件,CHNE是一家非营利性临终关怀机构,为佛罗里达州东北部90%以上的临终关怀患者提供服务。134名晚期乳腺癌患者由临终关怀护士通过胸壁检查评估是否存在LRR。其中80%(107名)为白人,17%(23名)为非裔美国人,3%(4名)为其他种族。13%的女性(17/134)有LRR证据。非裔美国女性中LRR患者的比例高于白人女性(分别为26%和10%,6/23和11/107),尽管这种差异无统计学意义(p = 0.08)。大多数有LRR的白人女性同意进行病历审查,但少数非裔美国女性同意(分别为8/11和2/6,p = 0.16)。
通过审查由临终关怀项目服务的患者数据来评估乳腺癌护理结果的差异是可行的,这些项目为社区内的大多数患者提供帮助。这些初步数据表明,患有乳腺癌的非裔美国女性作为其晚期乳腺癌疾病的一部分,局部区域失败的发生率高于白人女性。同意参与病历审查研究的非裔美国患者和家庭比例低于白人。需要进行更大规模的研究来证实这些发现,阐明导致差异的因素,并制定潜在的解决方案。