Fung Winky Wing Ki, Wu Vincent Wing Cheung, Teo Peter Man Lung
Department of Radiotherapy, Hong Kong Sanatorium and Hospital, Hong Kong.
Med Dosim. 2012 Spring;37(1):92-7. doi: 10.1016/j.meddos.2011.01.006. Epub 2011 Sep 25.
Adaptive radiotherapy (ART) has been introduced to correct the radiation-induced anatomic changes in head and neck cases during a treatment course. This study evaluated the potential dosimetric benefits of applying a 3-phase adaptive radiotherapy protocol in nasopharyngeal carcinoma (NPC) patients compared with the nonadaptive single-phase treatment protocol. Ten NPC patients previously treated with this 3-phase radiation protocol using Hi-Art Tomotherapy were recruited. Two new plans, PII-ART and PIII-ART, were generated based on the up-to-date computed tomography (CT) images and contours and were used for treatment in phase two (PII; after 25th fraction) and phase three (PIII; after 35th fraction), respectively. To simulate the situation of no replanning, 2 hybrid plans denoted as PII-NART and PIII-NART were generated using the original contours pasted on the PII- and PIII-CT sets by CT-CT fusion. Dosimetric comparisons were made between the NART plans and the corresponding ART plans. In both PII- and PIII-NART plans, the doses to 95% of all the target volumes (D₉₅) were increased with better dose uniformity, whereas the organs at risk (OARs) received higher doses compared with the corresponding ART plans. Without replanning, the total dose to 1% of brainstem and spinal cord (D₁) significantly increased 7.87 ± 7.26% and 10.69 ± 6.72%, respectively (P = 0.011 and 0.001, respectively), in which 3 patients would have these structures overdosed when compared with those with two replannings. The total maximum doses to the optic chiasm and pituitary gland and the mean doses to the left and right parotid glands were increased by 10.50 ± 10.51%, 8.59 ± 6.10%, 3.03 ± 4.48%, and 2.24 ± 3.11%, respectively (P = 0.014, 0.003, 0.053, and 0.046, respectively). The 3-phase radiotherapy protocol showed improved dosimetric results to the critical structures while keeping satisfactory target dose coverage, which demonstrated the advantages of ART in helical tomotherapy of NPC.
自适应放疗(ART)已被引入,以纠正头颈部病例在治疗过程中因放疗引起的解剖结构变化。本研究评估了与非自适应单相治疗方案相比,在鼻咽癌(NPC)患者中应用三相自适应放疗方案的潜在剂量学益处。招募了10例先前使用Hi-Art螺旋断层放疗进行三相放疗方案治疗的NPC患者。根据最新的计算机断层扫描(CT)图像和轮廓生成了两个新计划,即PII-ART和PIII-ART,分别用于第二阶段(PII;第25次分割后)和第三阶段(PIII;第35次分割后)的治疗。为模拟不重新计划的情况,通过CT-CT融合将原始轮廓粘贴到PII-和PIII-CT数据集上,生成了两个混合计划,分别表示为PII-NART和PIII-NART。对NART计划和相应的ART计划进行了剂量学比较。在PII-和PIII-NART计划中,所有靶区体积的95%所接受的剂量(D₉₅)均增加,剂量均匀性更好,而与相应的ART计划相比,危及器官(OARs)接受的剂量更高。在不重新计划的情况下,脑干和脊髓1%所接受的总剂量(D₁)分别显著增加7.87±7.26%和10.69±6.72%(P分别为0.011和0.001),与进行两次重新计划的患者相比,有3例患者这些结构的剂量会超过限值。视交叉和垂体的总最大剂量以及左右腮腺的平均剂量分别增加了10.50±10.51%、8.59±6.10%、3.03±4.48%和2.24±3.11%(P分别为0.014、0.003、0.053和0.046)。三相放疗方案在保持满意的靶区剂量覆盖的同时,对关键结构显示出更好的剂量学结果,这证明了ART在NPC螺旋断层放疗中的优势。