Department of Gynecology and Obstetrics, University Hospital Ulm, Prittwitzstrasse 43, 89075 Ulm, Germany.
Breast. 2012 Apr;21(2):171-7. doi: 10.1016/j.breast.2011.09.007. Epub 2011 Sep 25.
This retrospective multi-centre study is focussed on recurrence free and overall survival of bilateral breast cancer (BBC) versus unilateral breast cancer (UBC). The impact of BBC on survival is stratified to guideline adherence, according to the German national S3-guideline. Another aim of the study is to identify the influence of various guideline violations in adjuvant treatment on survival of BBC patients. 229 (4.3%) patients had BBC and 5063 (95.7%) had UBC. There is a significant association between BBC/UBC and recurrence free (RFS: p < 0.001) and overall survival (OAS: p = 0.003). Only 15.7% of patients with BBC are treated 100% guideline adherent (index- + contralateral tumour). 31.0% (30.5%) were guideline adherent with respect to the index (contralateral) tumour. The outcome decreases significantly with the number of guideline violations. There was no significant difference in RFS and OAS between BBC and UBC after adjusting for tumour size, nodal status, grading and if guideline adherent treatment was applied.
目的:本回顾性多中心研究主要聚焦于双侧乳腺癌(BBC)与单侧乳腺癌(UBC)患者的无复发生存(RFS)和总生存(OAS)。根据德国国家 S3 指南,将 BBC 对生存的影响分层为指南依从性。该研究的另一个目的是确定辅助治疗中各种指南违反对 BBC 患者生存的影响。
方法:研究纳入了 229 例 BBC 患者(4.3%)和 5063 例 UBC 患者(95.7%)。BBC/UBC 与 RFS(p<0.001)和 OAS(p=0.003)显著相关。仅有 15.7%的 BBC 患者接受了 100%的指南依从性治疗(同侧+对侧肿瘤)。31.0%(30.5%)的患者在同侧(对侧)肿瘤方面遵循指南。随着指南违反数量的增加,结局显著下降。在调整肿瘤大小、淋巴结状态、分级和是否应用指南依从性治疗后,BBC 和 UBC 患者的 RFS 和 OAS 无显著差异。
结论:1. 与单纯 UBC 患者相比,BBC 患者的 RFS 和 OAS 预后较差。2. 患者的 BBC 或 UBC 的 RFS/OAS 与指南依从性之间存在密切关联,随着指南违反数量的增加,结局显著下降。3. 如果应用了指南依从性治疗(对于 BBC 患者的双侧肿瘤),在调整肿瘤大小、淋巴结状态、分级后,BBC 和 UBC 患者的 RFS 和 OAS 无显著差异。