Thompson Nellie L
New York Psychoanalytic Society and Institute, USA.
J Am Psychoanal Assoc. 2011 Oct;59(5):1009-22. doi: 10.1177/0003065111422907. Epub 2011 Sep 26.
In 1956, the year before his death, Ernst Kris published a trilogy of papers on memory--"The Personal Myth," "On Some Vicissitudes of Insight in Psychoanalysis," and "The Recovery of Childhood Memories"--and was planning to publish a monograph on the subject. In his papers on memory, by juxtaposing his clinical work with adult patients and his research on very young children, Kris sketched a trajectory of the dynamic relationship between preoedipal ego development and object relations, against the backdrop of psychosexual stages and the defenses that mediate memory. Kris was firmly committed to the premise that "the development of ego functions and object relations . . . are of equal and intrinsic importance." This paper explores how Kris's papers on memory may also be read as delineating his thinking on the role of object relations in infants and young children. In his last paper, the posthumously published "Decline and Recovery in the Life of a Three-Year-Old" (1962), his interest in ego development and object relations shifts to object relations, but the role of memory remains crucial. The paper concludes with some observations about the omissions and distortions that characterize how the history of psychoanalysis is recalled, orally transmitted, and written.
1956年,即恩斯特·克里斯去世的前一年,他发表了关于记忆的三部曲论文——《个人神话》《精神分析中洞察力的某些变迁》以及《童年记忆的恢复》——并且正计划出版一本关于该主题的专著。在他关于记忆的论文中,通过将他对成年患者的临床工作与对幼儿的研究并列起来,克里斯勾勒出了前俄狄浦斯期自我发展与客体关系之间动态关系的轨迹,以性心理发展阶段以及调节记忆的防御机制为背景。克里斯坚定地秉持这样一个前提,即“自我功能和客体关系的发展……具有同等的内在重要性”。本文探讨了如何也能将克里斯关于记忆的论文解读为描绘了他对客体关系在婴幼儿中所起作用的思考。在他的最后一篇论文,即死后发表的《一个三岁儿童生活中的衰退与恢复》(1962年)中,他对自我发展和客体关系的兴趣转向了客体关系,但记忆的作用仍然至关重要。本文最后对精神分析历史在被回忆、口头传承和书写过程中所具有的遗漏和扭曲特征进行了一些观察。