De Renzi Silvia
The Open University.
Renaiss Stud. 2007 Sep;21(4):551-567. doi: 10.1111/j.1477-4658.2007.00462.x.
At the centre of this article are two physicians active in Rome between 1600 and 1630 who combined medical practice with broader involvement in the dynamic cultural, economic and political scene of the centre of the Catholic world. The city's distinctive and very influential social landscape magnified issues of career-building and allows us to recapture physicians' different strategies of self-fashioning at a time of major social and religious reorganization. At one level, reconstructing Johannes Faber and Giulio Mancini's medical education, arrival in Rome and overlapping but different career trajectories contributes to research on physicians' identity in early modern Italian states. Most remarkable are their access to different segments of Roman society, including a dynamic art market, and their diplomatic and political role, claimed as well as real. But following these physicians from hospitals to courts, including that of the Pope, and from tribunals to the university and analysing the wide range of their writing - from medico-legal consilia to political essays and reports of anatomical investigations - also enriches our view of medical practice, which included, but went beyond, the bedside. Furthermore, their activities demand that we reassess the complex place of anatomical investigations in a courtly society, and start recovering the fundamental role played by hospitals - those quintessential Catholic institutions - as sites of routine dissections for both medical teaching and research. (pp. 551-567).
本文的核心是两位在1600年至1630年间活跃于罗马的医生,他们将医疗实践与更广泛地参与天主教世界中心充满活力的文化、经济和政治舞台结合起来。这座城市独特且极具影响力的社会格局放大了职业发展问题,并使我们能够重新捕捉到在重大社会和宗教重组时期医生们自我塑造的不同策略。在一个层面上,重构约翰内斯·法贝尔和朱利奥·曼奇尼的医学教育、抵达罗马以及重叠但不同的职业轨迹,有助于对近代早期意大利各邦国医生身份的研究。最引人注目的是他们能够接触到罗马社会的不同阶层,包括充满活力的艺术市场,以及他们宣称的和实际的外交与政治角色。但是,跟随这些医生从医院到宫廷,包括教皇的宫廷,从法庭到大学,并分析他们广泛的著述——从医学法律意见书到政治论文和解剖学调查报道——也丰富了我们对医疗实践的看法,这种实践包括但不限于床边诊疗。此外,他们的活动要求我们重新评估解剖学调查在宫廷社会中的复杂地位,并开始重新认识医院——那些典型的天主教机构——作为医学教学和研究常规解剖场所所发挥的重要作用。(第551 - 567页)