Sinclair John C, Bottino Marcela, Cowett Richard M
Departments of Pediatrics and Clinical Epidemiology and Biostatistics, McMaster University, 1280 Main Street West, CRL Room B106, Hamilton, Ontario, Canada, L8S 4K1.
Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2011 Oct 5(10):CD007615. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD007615.pub3.
Among very low birth weight (VLBW) infants, early neonatal hyperglycemia is common and is associated with increased risks for death and major morbidities. It is uncertain whether hyperglycemia per se is a cause of adverse clinical outcomes or whether outcomes can be improved by preventing hyperglycemia.
To assess effects on clinical outcomes of interventions for preventing hyperglycemia in VLBW neonates receiving full or partial parenteral nutrition.
We searched the Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials (CENTRAL) in The Cochrane Library, issue 4 of 12, 2011; MEDLINE (1966 to April 2011); EMBASE (1980 to April 2011); CINAHL (1982 to Nov 2008); abstracts of Pediatric Academic Societies 2000 to 2011 and European Society for Pediatric Research 2005 to 2010.
Randomized or quasi-randomized controlled trials of interventions for prevention of hyperglycemia in neonates with birth weight < 1500 g or gestational age < 32 wk.
Two review authors independently selected studies for eligibility and extracted data on study design, methods, clinical features, and treatment outcomes. Included trials were assessed for blinding of randomization, intervention and outcome measurement, and completeness of follow-up. Treatment effect measures for categorical outcomes were relative risk and risk difference, and for continuous outcomes, mean difference, each with their 95% confidence intervals.
We detected four eligible trials. Two trials compared lower versus higher rates of glucose infusion in the early postnatal period. These trials were too small to assess effects on mortality or major morbidities. Two trials, one a moderately large multicentre trial (NIRTURE, Beardsall 2008), compared insulin infusion with standard care. Insulin infusion reduced hyperglycemia but increased death before 28 days and hypoglycemia. Reduction in hyperglycemia was not accompanied by significant effects on major morbidities; effects on neurodevelopment are awaited.
AUTHORS' CONCLUSIONS: Glucose infusion rate: There is insufficient evidence from trials comparing lower with higher glucose infusion rates to inform clinical practice. Large randomized trials are needed, powered on clinical outcomes including death, major morbidities and adverse neurodevelopment.Insulin infusion: The evidence reviewed does not support the routine use of insulin infusions to prevent hyperglycemia in VLBW neonates. Further randomized trials of insulin infusion may be justified. They should enrol extremely low birth weight neonates at very high risk for hyperglycemia and neonatal death. They might use real time glucose monitors if these are validated for clinical use. Refinement of algorithms to guide insulin infusion is needed to enable tight control of glucose concentrations within the target range.
在极低出生体重(VLBW)婴儿中,早期新生儿高血糖很常见,且与死亡及严重疾病风险增加相关。高血糖本身是否为不良临床结局的原因,以及通过预防高血糖能否改善结局尚不确定。
评估对接受全肠外营养或部分肠外营养的极低出生体重新生儿预防高血糖干预措施的临床结局影响。
我们检索了《Cochrane图书馆》2011年第12期第4卷的Cochrane对照试验中心注册库(CENTRAL);MEDLINE(1966年至2011年4月);EMBASE(1980年至2011年4月);护理学与健康领域数据库(CINAHL,1982年至2008年11月);2000年至2011年儿科学术协会摘要以及2005年至2010年欧洲儿科学研究协会摘要。
出生体重<1500g或胎龄<32周的新生儿预防高血糖干预措施的随机或半随机对照试验。
两名综述作者独立选择符合条件的研究,并提取关于研究设计、方法、临床特征和治疗结局的数据。对纳入试验的随机化、干预和结局测量的盲法以及随访完整性进行评估。分类结局的治疗效果测量指标为相对危险度和危险度差值,连续结局的指标为平均差值,均伴有95%置信区间。
我们检索到四项符合条件的试验。两项试验比较了出生后早期较低与较高葡萄糖输注率。这些试验规模太小,无法评估对死亡率或严重疾病的影响。两项试验,其中一项是规模适中的多中心试验(NIRTURE,Beardsall 2008),比较了胰岛素输注与标准治疗。胰岛素输注降低了高血糖,但增加了28天内的死亡和低血糖。高血糖的降低并未伴随对严重疾病的显著影响;对神经发育的影响有待观察。
葡萄糖输注率:比较较低与较高葡萄糖输注率的试验证据不足,无法为临床实践提供参考。需要进行大型随机试验,以死亡、严重疾病和不良神经发育等临床结局为指标。胰岛素输注:所综述的证据不支持在极低出生体重新生儿中常规使用胰岛素输注预防高血糖。进一步的胰岛素输注随机试验可能是合理的。试验应纳入高血糖和新生儿死亡风险极高的超低出生体重新生儿。如果实时血糖监测仪经临床验证可用,则可使用。需要完善指导胰岛素输注的算法,以便将血糖浓度严格控制在目标范围内。