Al-Kaisy A A, Salih Sahib A
Department of Surgery, Burn Unit, Baquba General Hospital, Diyala, Iraq.
Ann Burns Fire Disasters. 2005 Mar 31;18(1):19-30.
Objective. Burns represent a major health problem worldwide, with high mortality and morbidity and economic loss even with small burns. Changes in medical treatment protocols depending on a new mechanism involved in the pathogenicity of burns, i.e. oxidative stress (such as the use of povidone-iodine alone or in combination with vitamin E and vitamin C) may improve the outcome and reduce the economic loss. Patients and methods. Thirty-eight thermally injured patients of different age groups, sex, and occupation with different burn size, admitted to the burn unit in Baquba General Hospital, Iraq, were involved in this clinical trial. The patients were allocated to three groups: group A (8 patients), treated according to hospital policy; group B (17 patients), treated with topical povidone-iodine ointment; and group C (13 patients), treated with topical povidone-iodine ointment with systemic once daily 400 mg vitamin E and 500 mg vitamin C in addition to the classical antibiotic used by our hospital. In each group of oxidative stress parameters, the thyroid, liver, and kidney function test, microbiological studies, the mortality rate and healing time measurements, and economic studies were performed using standard methods. Results. Treatment with topical povidone-iodine ointment or in combination with systemic vitamin E and vitamin C was found to be of significant benefit in improving oxidative stress parameters, the mortality rate, healing time, and cost, and was free of any adverse thyroid, hepatic, or renal effects. Conclusion. Treatment of thermally injured patients with topical povidone-iodine ointment significantly improved oxidative stress parameters, indicating its antioxidant effect. Further investigation is needed to explain the exact mechanism by which povidone-iodine exerts this antioxidant effect. Treatment with topical povidone-iodine ointment alone or in combination with systemic vitamin E and vitamin C significantly improves the outcome of thermally injured patients in a safe way, thanks to the newly emerged mechanism - oxidative stress - involved in burns pathogenesis.
目的。烧伤是全球范围内的一个主要健康问题,即便轻度烧伤也会导致高死亡率、高发病率以及经济损失。依据烧伤致病新机制(即氧化应激,如单独使用聚维酮碘或联合维生素E和维生素C)改变医疗治疗方案,可能改善治疗效果并减少经济损失。
患者与方法。伊拉克巴古拜总医院烧伤科收治的38例不同年龄、性别和职业且烧伤面积各异的热损伤患者参与了此项临床试验。患者被分为三组:A组(8例患者),按照医院常规治疗;B组(17例患者),外用聚维酮碘软膏治疗;C组(13例患者),外用聚维酮碘软膏,同时每天口服400毫克维生素E和500毫克维生素C,此外还使用我院常规使用的抗生素。在每组中,采用标准方法进行氧化应激参数、甲状腺、肝脏和肾脏功能检测、微生物学研究、死亡率及愈合时间测量以及经济学研究。
结果。发现外用聚维酮碘软膏或联合维生素E和维生素C进行全身治疗在改善氧化应激参数、死亡率、愈合时间及成本方面具有显著益处,且未产生任何甲状腺、肝脏或肾脏不良影响。
结论。外用聚维酮碘软膏治疗热损伤患者可显著改善氧化应激参数,表明其具有抗氧化作用。需要进一步研究以解释聚维酮碘发挥这种抗氧化作用的确切机制。由于烧伤发病机制中涉及新出现的氧化应激机制,单独外用聚维酮碘软膏或联合维生素E和维生素C进行全身治疗能以安全的方式显著改善热损伤患者的治疗效果。