Center for Community Studies, Peabody College of Education & Human Development, Vanderbilt University, Nashville, TN 37203, USA.
Health Educ Behav. 2012 Oct;39(5):526-37. doi: 10.1177/1090198111419656. Epub 2011 Oct 14.
Community coalitions are a recognized strategy for addressing pressing public health problems. Despite the promise of coalitions as an effective prevention strategy, results linking coalition efforts to positive community outcomes are mixed. To date, research has primarily focused on determining organizational attributes related to successful internal coalition functioning. The authors' research complements and adds to this literature by offering a network conceptualization of coalition formation in which coalition participation is studied within the broader context of local organizational networks both within and beyond a coalition. The authors examine participation in the first year of a youth violence prevention coalition exploring both differences between participating and nonparticipating organizations and levels of participation. Each network variable, reflecting prior collaboration and being viewed by other organizations as a local leader, approximately doubled the explained variance in coalition participation beyond the predictive power of all available organizational attributes combined. Results suggest that initial coalition participation emerged out of a preexisting network of interorganizational relations and provide an alternative perspective on coalition formation that goes beyond conceptual orientations that treat coalitions as bounded organizational entities that exist apart from the communities in which they are embedded.
社区联盟是解决紧迫公共卫生问题的一种公认策略。尽管联盟作为一种有效的预防策略具有很大的潜力,但将联盟努力与积极的社区成果联系起来的结果却是好坏参半。迄今为止,研究主要集中在确定与成功的内部联盟运作相关的组织属性上。作者的研究通过提供一种联盟形成的网络概念化来补充和扩展这一文献,在这种概念化中,联盟参与在联盟内外的本地组织网络的更广泛背景下进行研究。作者研究了青年暴力预防联盟第一年的参与情况,探讨了参与组织和非参与组织之间的差异以及参与程度。每个网络变量都反映了之前的合作关系,并且被其他组织视为本地领导者,除了所有可用组织属性的综合预测能力之外,这些变量大约将联盟参与的可解释方差增加了一倍。研究结果表明,最初的联盟参与是从组织间关系的现有网络中产生的,并为联盟形成提供了一种替代视角,这种视角超越了将联盟视为与它们所嵌入的社区分开的有界组织实体的概念取向。