Department of Periodontics and Oral Medicine, School of Dentistry, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, 48109-1078, USA.
Angle Orthod. 2011 Nov;81(6):1090-6. doi: 10.2319/013111-64.1.
To explore whether orthodontic residents and orthodontists differ in their attitudes and behavior concerning the treatment of underserved patients and to investigate how background factors such as the providers' gender, ethnicity/race, and age affect these attitudes and behavior.
Survey data were collected from 135 residents in US and Canadian graduate orthodontic programs and from 568 active members of the American Association of Orthodontists. Attitudes toward various aspects of treating underserved patients were rated on a five-point scale, with 1 indicating the most negative attitude and 5 indicating the most positive.
Orthodontic residents had more positive attitudes about treating poor patients (3.02 vs 1.99; P < .001), pro bono cases (3.87 vs. 3.45; P < .001), and patients with craniofacial anomalies (3.64 vs 3.01; P < .001) or mental retardation (3.13 vs 2.72; P < .001) than orthodontists. However, compared to orthodontists, lower percentages of residents intended to treat pro bono cases (73.5% vs 83%; P = .009) and patients with craniofacial anomalies (63.6% vs 82.9%; P < .001) or mental retardation (55% vs 81.5%; P < .001). The providers' gender did not have an effect on these attitudes and related behavior, while ethnicity/race and age of the providers were relevant.
Residents had more positive attitudes concerning the treatment of underserved patients than orthodontists. However, their behavioral intentions did not indicate an increased willingness to provide care for these patients.
探讨正畸住院医师和正畸医师在对待服务不足患者的态度和行为上是否存在差异,并调查提供者的性别、种族/民族和年龄等背景因素如何影响这些态度和行为。
调查数据来自美国和加拿大的 135 名正畸住院医师和美国正畸医师协会的 568 名在职成员。通过五点量表对治疗服务不足患者的各个方面的态度进行评分,1 表示最消极的态度,5 表示最积极的态度。
正畸住院医师对治疗贫困患者(3.02 对 1.99;P <.001)、免费病例(3.87 对 3.45;P <.001)和颅面畸形(3.64 对 3.01;P <.001)或智力障碍(3.13 对 2.72;P <.001)的患者的态度更为积极。然而,与正畸医师相比,住院医师中打算治疗免费病例(73.5%对 83%;P =.009)和颅面畸形(63.6%对 82.9%;P <.001)或智力障碍(55%对 81.5%;P <.001)的患者的比例较低。提供者的性别对这些态度和相关行为没有影响,而提供者的种族/民族和年龄则相关。
住院医师对治疗服务不足患者的态度比正畸医师更为积极。然而,他们的行为意图并没有表明他们更愿意为这些患者提供护理。