Willems A R, Tijssen J G, van Capelle F J, Kingma J H, Hauer R N, Vermeulen F E, Brugada P, van Hoogenhuyze D C, Janse M J
Department of Experimental Cardiology, Academic Medical Center, Amsterdam, The Netherlands.
J Am Coll Cardiol. 1990 Sep;16(3):521-30. doi: 10.1016/0735-1097(90)90336-n.
In a multicenter study, 390 patients with sustained symptomatic ventricular tachycardia or ventricular fibrillation late after acute myocardial infarction were prospectively followed up to assess determinants of mortality and recurrence of arrhythmic events. Patients were given standard antiarrhythmic treatment, which consisted primarily of drug therapy. During a mean follow-up period of 1.9 years, 133 patients (34%) died; arrhythmic events and heart failure were the most common cause of death (41 patients [11%] died suddenly, 31 [8%] died because of recurrent ventricular tachycardia or ventricular fibrillation and 23 [6%] died of heart failure). One hundred ninety-two patients (49%) had at least one recurrent arrhythmic event; 85% of first recurrent arrhythmic events were nonfatal. Multivariate analysis of data from patients who developed the arrhythmia less than 6 weeks after infarction identified five variables as independent determinants of total mortality: 1) age greater than 70 years (risk ratio 4.5); 2) Killip class III or IV in the subacute phase of infarction (risk ratio 3.5); 3) cardiac arrest during the index arrhythmia (risk ratio 1.7); 4) anterior infarction (risk ratio 2.2); and 5) multiple previous infarctions (risk ratio 1.6). Multivariate analysis of data from patients developing the arrhythmia greater than 6 weeks after infarction identified four variables as independently predictive of total mortality: 1) Q wave infarction (risk ratio 2.1); 2) cardiac arrest during the index arrhythmia (risk ratio 1.7); 3) Killip class III or IV in the subacute phase of infarction (risk ratio 1.7); and 4) multiple previous infarctions (risk ratio 1.4). The results of the two multivariate analyses were used in a model for prediction of mortality at 1 year. The average predicted mortality rate varied considerably according to the model: for 243 patients (62%) with the lowest risk, it was 13%, corresponding to an observed mortality rate of 12%; for 92 patients (24%) with intermediate risk, it was 27%, corresponding to an observed rate of 28%; for 55 patients (14%) with the highest risk, it was 64%, corresponding to an observed rate of 54%. This study shows that patients with symptomatic ventricular tachycardia or ventricular fibrillation late after myocardial infarction who are given standard antiarrhythmic treatment have a high mortality rate. The predictive model presented identifies patients at low, intermediate and high risk of death and can be of help in designing the appropriate diagnostic and therapeutic strategy for the individual patient.
在一项多中心研究中,对390例急性心肌梗死后晚期出现持续性症状性室性心动过速或室颤的患者进行了前瞻性随访,以评估死亡和心律失常事件复发的决定因素。患者接受了标准的抗心律失常治疗,主要包括药物治疗。在平均1.9年的随访期内,133例患者(34%)死亡;心律失常事件和心力衰竭是最常见的死亡原因(41例患者[11%]猝死,31例[8%]死于复发性室性心动过速或室颤,23例[6%]死于心力衰竭)。192例患者(49%)至少发生过一次心律失常事件复发;首次心律失常事件复发的85%为非致死性。对梗死发生后不到6周出现心律失常的患者数据进行多变量分析,确定了五个变量为总死亡率的独立决定因素:1)年龄大于70岁(风险比4.5);2)梗死亚急性期Killip分级III级或IV级(风险比3.5);3)首次心律失常发作时心脏骤停(风险比1.7);4)前壁梗死(风险比2.2);5)既往多次梗死(风险比1.6)。对梗死发生6周后出现心律失常的患者数据进行多变量分析,确定了四个变量可独立预测总死亡率:1)Q波梗死(风险比2.1);2)首次心律失常发作时心脏骤停(风险比1.7);3)梗死亚急性期Killip分级III级或IV级(风险比1.7);4)既往多次梗死(风险比1.4)。这两项多变量分析的结果被用于一个预测1年死亡率 的模型。根据该模型,平均预测死亡率差异很大:对于243例(62%)低风险患者,为13%,对应观察到的死亡率为12%;对于92例(24%)中风险患者,为27%,对应观察到 的死亡率为28%;对于55例(14%)高风险患者,为64%,对应观察到的死亡率为54%。这项研究表明,接受标准抗心律失常治疗的心肌梗死后晚期出现症状性室性心动过速或室颤的患者死亡率很高。所提出的预测模型可识别出低、中、高死亡风险的患者,并有助于为个体患者设计合适的诊断和治疗策略。